Skip to content

Free-response practice

FRQ 1

10 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

FRQ 1 is the first of the three free-response questions on the AP Environmental Science exam. It describes a real or realistic study, such as a laboratory experiment, a field survey or a long-term monitoring project, and then asks you to reason like the scientist who designed it. The stimulus is usually a short passage explaining what the researchers did, followed by a table, graph or diagram of their results. The parts are labelled (a), (b), (c) and so on, and some contain sub-parts.

On this page · 6 sections

Roughly half the points test experimental design. You identify the independent and dependent variables, state a hypothesis or null hypothesis, and identify a control group or a variable that was held constant. You may also have to explain why a particular design choice, like repeated trials or multiple sampling sites, makes the results more trustworthy, or propose a way to improve the method. The remaining points test environmental science content: you interpret the data, explain the mechanism that produced the results, and connect them to a consequence or a solution. The study itself can come from any unit of the course.

The free-response section gives you 70 minutes for three questions and counts for 40% of your exam score. Each question is worth 10 points, so FRQ 1 by itself represents roughly 13% of your total score. Budget about 23 minutes for it, which leaves enough time for FRQ 2 and for the calculation question, FRQ 3.

Readers score every point independently, so a mistake in part (a) does not prevent you from earning part (e). When a part asks for one answer, readers generally score only the first one you give, which means listing three guesses earns nothing extra and can cost you if the first is wrong. The task verb tells you how much to write: - "Identify" requires a specific, correct name, variable or value, and one sentence is usually enough. - "Describe" requires the relevant details, such as what is measured and how it is measured. - "Explain" requires a cause-and-effect chain that says how or why something happens.

Precision is what earns points on this question. "The fish" is not a dependent variable, because a variable must be something you can measure, whereas "the number of fish caught per net per hour" is. Spelling and grammar do not affect your score unless they make your meaning unclear.

The rubric, in plain terms

10 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Independent and dependent variables2 pts

One point for naming the factor the researchers changed or compared on purpose (the independent variable). One point for naming the quantity they measured as the outcome (the dependent variable). Each answer must be a measurable quantity from this study, not a general topic or an organism. "Seawater pH" earns the point, but "the ocean" does not. Swapping the two loses both points.

Hypothesis or null hypothesis1 pt

Write the kind of hypothesis the part asks for, linking the independent variable to the dependent variable in a way the study could test. A null hypothesis says the independent variable has no effect, or that the groups show no difference. An alternative hypothesis predicts an effect, often with a direction such as "more" or "lower". A prediction stated where a null hypothesis was asked for does not earn the point.

Control group or controlled variable1 pt

Answer the specific term the part uses. A controlled variable (a constant) is a condition kept the same in every trial, such as water temperature or sampling date. A control group is the untreated baseline the other groups are compared against. If the part asks why a condition was kept the same, say that it keeps that condition from causing the differences in the results.

Justify or improve a design choice1 pt

Explain why one feature of the method improves the study, or name a factor that could confound the results. For repeated trials or several sample sites, say that one unusual trial or site cannot decide the outcome, because averaging reduces the effect of random variation. If the part asks for an improvement, name a specific change to the method, such as taking three kick-net samples per stream instead of one. "To make it more accurate" or "to get more data" alone is too vague to earn credit.

Use the data1 pt

Pull a correct trend, value or calculation from the table or graph. A trend needs a direction plus supporting numbers from the data, for example that shell completion dropped from 92% at pH 8.1 to 34% at pH 7.5. A calculation needs the setup, meaning the numbers you add and divide, plus the correct answer with units where the quantity has them. A bare final value without setup usually does not earn the point.

Explain the environmental mechanism2 pts

Give the cause-and-effect steps that explain why the results came out as they did, one point per correct step. For ocean acidification, one step is that dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid and lowers pH. A second step is that the extra hydrogen ions bind carbonate ions, leaving less carbonate to build calcium carbonate shells. "The acid dissolves the shells" is incomplete rather than false, because water low in carbonate can dissolve existing shells. A question about building shells needs the carbonate step, so that answer earns the first step only.

Apply the results2 pts

Connect the study to the wider world, one point for each piece the part asks for. Usually the first point is a specific, realistic solution, consequence or ecosystem service. The second point explains how that solution works, or how the harm in the study reduces that service. Chemically impossible fixes and vague answers like "it would hurt the environment" earn nothing.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Seawater pH and Oyster Larvae Shell Formation

Managers at the Pell Cove Shellfish Hatchery, a commercial hatchery on the Pacific coast of the United States, noticed that batches of young oysters were dying more often in years when upwelled seawater was more acidic. A team of biologists designed an experiment to test how seawater pH affects shell formation in Pacific oyster larvae.

The biologists set up 12 identical tanks. They adjusted the seawater in three tanks to each of four pH values: 8.1, 7.9, 7.7 and 7.5. Each tank received 1,000 newly hatched larvae. Every tank was held at 20°C and received the same amount of the same algae as food each day. After 14 days, the biologists sampled the larvae in each tank under a microscope. They recorded the percentage of larvae with a complete shell and the mean shell length. The table shows the mean of the three tanks at each pH.

Seawater pH | Larvae with a complete shell (%) | Mean shell length (micrometers) 8.1 | 92 | 210 7.9 | 85 | 196 7.7 | 61 | 168 7.5 | 34 | 131

  1. (a)Identify the independent variable in this experiment. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Identify one dependent variable in this experiment. [1 pt]
  3. (c)Identify one variable that the biologists held constant across all 12 tanks. [1 pt]
  4. (d)State a null hypothesis for this experiment. [1 pt]
  5. (e)Explain why the biologists used three tanks at each pH value instead of one. [1 pt]
  6. (f)Using the data, describe the relationship between seawater pH and the percentage of larvae with a complete shell. [1 pt]
  7. (g)Explain how rising carbon dioxide in the atmosphere reduces the ability of oyster larvae to build their shells. [2 pts]
  8. (h)Describe one ecosystem service that wild oyster reefs provide. Then explain how ocean acidification could reduce that service. [2 pts]
Prompt 2

Bedrock, Acid Deposition and Stream Insects

Corran Ridge is a forested mountain area in the northeastern United States. It lies downwind of several large coal-fired power plants. A high school environmental science class wanted to know whether the type of bedrock under a stream affects how acid deposition harms stream life.

The students chose eight small streams on the ridge. Four streams drain watersheds underlain by granite, and four drain watersheds underlain by limestone. All eight watersheds are forested and receive about the same amount of acid deposition. On two days in April, shortly after the snow melted, the students measured the pH of each stream. The pH in the table is the mean of the two readings. On the first of those two days, they also took one timed kick-net sample at each stream and counted the mayfly nymphs. Mayflies are aquatic insects that are sensitive to low pH.

Stream | Bedrock | Stream pH | Mayfly nymphs per sample G1 | Granite | 5.2 | 3 G2 | Granite | 5.4 | 6 G3 | Granite | 5.0 | 1 G4 | Granite | 5.5 | 8 L1 | Limestone | 7.4 | 41 L2 | Limestone | 7.6 | 38 L3 | Limestone | 7.2 | 33 L4 | Limestone | 7.8 | 46

  1. (a)Identify the independent variable in this investigation. [1 pt]
  2. (b)Identify one dependent variable in this investigation. [1 pt]
  3. (c)Write a testable hypothesis that the students could have made before they collected the data. [1 pt]
  4. (d)The students sampled all eight streams on the same two days. Explain why sampling every stream at the same time improves the investigation. [1 pt]
  5. (e)Calculate the mean pH of the granite streams and the mean pH of the limestone streams. Show your work. [1 pt]
  6. (f)The students took only one kick-net sample at each stream, on a single day. Describe one way the students could improve the design of this investigation. [1 pt]
  7. (g)All eight streams receive about the same amount of acid deposition. Explain why the limestone streams have a higher pH than the granite streams. [2 pts]
  8. (h)Propose one solution that would reduce acid deposition at Corran Ridge at its source. Describe how the solution reduces acid deposition. [2 pts]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Seawater pH and Oyster Larvae Shell Formation · high-scoring response10/10

(a) The independent variable is the pH of the seawater in the tanks (8.1, 7.9, 7.7 or 7.5).

(b) The percentage of larvae that had a complete shell after 14 days.

(c) The water temperature, which was 20°C in every tank.

(d) Seawater pH has no effect on the percentage of oyster larvae that form a complete shell.

(e) If they only used one tank per pH, something random like a sick batch of larvae or a broken heater in that one tank could change the result and they would think it was the pH. With three tanks they can average the results, so one unusual tank has less effect and the results are more reliable.

(f) As the pH goes down, fewer larvae have complete shells. At pH 8.1 it was 92% but at 7.5 it was only 34%. The drop gets bigger below 7.9, from 85% to 61% to 34%.

(g) CO2 from the air dissolves into the ocean and reacts with water to make carbonic acid. The carbonic acid releases hydrogen ions, which lowers the pH. The extra hydrogen ions combine with carbonate ions and turn them into bicarbonate, so there are fewer carbonate ions in the water. Oyster larvae need carbonate ions and calcium to build calcium carbonate shells, so with less carbonate they can't finish their shells or the shells are smaller.

(h) Oyster reefs filter the water. Each oyster pulls in water and filters out algae and sediment while it feeds, which makes the water clearer. If acidification kills most larvae before they can build shells, fewer young oysters settle on the reef to replace the old ones. The reef shrinks, so less water gets filtered and the water gets murkier.

How it scored

1/1a — Names seawater pH, which is the factor the biologists deliberately set for each group of tanks.
1/1b — Names a measured outcome, the percentage of larvae with a complete shell; mean shell length would also have earned the point.
1/1c — Water temperature is stated in the stimulus as 20°C in every tank, so it qualifies as a controlled variable. The type and amount of food would also count.
1/1d — A correct null hypothesis, because it states that pH has no effect and names the specific outcome being measured.
1/1e — Explains that a single unusual tank could distort the result and that averaging across three tanks reduces random variation. The concrete examples make the reasoning easy for a reader to credit.
1/1f — Gives the direction of the trend and supports it with values from the table. The observation that the decline steepens below pH 7.9 is accurate but was not required.
2/2g — Both steps are present. Dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid and lowers pH (1), and the hydrogen ions convert carbonate into bicarbonate, leaving less carbonate available for calcium carbonate shells (1).
2/2h — Water filtration is a genuine ecosystem service of oyster reefs (1). The answer then traces how larval failure means fewer young oysters join the reef, so less water is filtered (1).
Seawater pH and Oyster Larvae Shell Formation · mid-scoring response5/10

(a) The pH of the water.

(b) The oysters.

(c) The tanks at pH 8.1 are the control because that is normal ocean pH.

(d) The pH of the seawater will not have any effect on whether the oyster larvae grow complete shells.

(e) So that they have more data and the experiment is more accurate.

(f) When the pH is lower the larvae have less complete shells. At 8.1 there were 92% with complete shells and at 7.5 there were 34%.

(g) There is more CO2 in the atmosphere because of burning fossil fuels and the ocean absorbs it, and this makes the ocean more acidic. The acid in the water dissolves the shells of the oysters so they can't build them.

(h) Oysters give people food, which is a provisioning service, and people can sell them so it's good for the economy. Ocean acidification will make the water too acidic for the oysters to breathe, so they will die and there will be less oysters to eat.

How it scored

1/1a — Seawater pH is the correct independent variable, since it is the condition the biologists controlled.
0/1b — "The oysters" names the organisms being studied rather than a measured quantity. The answer needed the percentage with a complete shell or the mean shell length.
0/1c — The part asked for a variable held constant, but this answer describes a control group instead. Water temperature or food would have earned the point.
1/1d — A correct null hypothesis, because it states that pH will have no effect on shell formation.
0/1e — "More data" and "more accurate" do not explain the reason. The answer needed to say that averaging three tanks keeps one unusual tank from determining the result.
1/1f — Gives the correct direction of the trend and supports it with two values from the table.
1/2g — Absorbed CO2 making the ocean more acidic earns the first step (1). "The acid dissolves the shells" is incomplete rather than false, since water low in carbonate can dissolve existing shells. The question asks why larvae cannot build shells, though, so the second point needs the carbonate step: hydrogen ions bind carbonate ions, leaving too few to form calcium carbonate (0).
1/2h — Food for people is a real provisioning service (1). The second point is not earned because "too acidic to breathe" is not the mechanism the course teaches. The answer needed to say that larvae cannot build calcium carbonate shells, so fewer oysters survive to harvest size (0).
Bedrock, Acid Deposition and Stream Insects · high-scoring response9/10

(a) The type of bedrock under the stream (granite or limestone).

(b) The number of mayfly nymphs in each kick-net sample.

(c) Streams on limestone bedrock will be healthier for mayflies than streams on granite bedrock.

(d) Stream pH changes with the seasons, and right after snowmelt a lot of acid that built up in the snow all winter flows into the streams at once. If they measured the granite streams on one day and the limestone streams weeks later, the difference could be caused by the timing and not the bedrock. Sampling on the same days keeps the time and weather the same for every stream.

(e) Granite mean = (5.2 + 5.4 + 5.0 + 5.5) / 4 = 21.1 / 4 = 5.3 Limestone mean = (7.4 + 7.6 + 7.2 + 7.8) / 4 = 30.0 / 4 = 7.5

(f) They should take three kick-net samples in different spots at each stream on both days and average the counts. One sample could land in an unusually good or bad spot, and averaging several samples keeps one odd count from deciding the result.

(g) Limestone is made of calcium carbonate, which is a base. When acid rain soaks through the soil and over the limestone, the calcium carbonate reacts with the hydrogen ions and neutralizes them, so the stream water ends up close to neutral. This is called buffering capacity. Granite doesn't have calcium carbonate, so it can't neutralize the acid, and the acid goes straight into the stream and lowers its pH.

(h) The power plants could install scrubbers on their smokestacks. A scrubber sprays the exhaust with a wet mixture of lime or limestone, and the SO2 reacts with it and gets trapped as a solid before it leaves the stack. Less SO2 in the air means less sulfuric acid forms in clouds, so less acid falls on Corran Ridge.

How it scored

1/1a — Bedrock type is the factor the students deliberately compared when they chose which streams to sample.
1/1b — Mayfly nymphs per sample is a measured outcome, and stream pH would also have earned the point.
0/1c — "Healthier" is not something the students measured, so their methods could not test this hypothesis. Predicting more mayfly nymphs, or a higher pH, in the limestone streams would have earned the point.
1/1d — Explains that sampling on different dates would allow timing, such as the snowmelt acid pulse, to cause the difference instead of bedrock.
1/1e — Both means are correct and the setup is shown. Rounding 5.275 to 5.3 is acceptable.
1/1f — Proposes a specific change to the method, several kick-net samples per stream, and explains how averaging them reduces the effect of one unusual sample.
2/2g — Calcium carbonate in limestone reacts with and neutralizes hydrogen ions (1). Granite lacks carbonate minerals, so the acid reaches the stream without being neutralized (1).
2/2h — Scrubbers on coal plant smokestacks reduce emissions at the source (1). The answer also explains the mechanism: SO2 reacts with lime and is captured before release, so less sulfuric acid forms downwind (1).
Bedrock, Acid Deposition and Stream Insects · mid-scoring response4/10

(a) The pH of the stream.

(b) How many mayfly nymphs they found.

(c) If a stream is on limestone then it will have more mayflies than a stream on granite, because the water will be less acidic.

(d) So that the experiment is fair.

(e) Granite: 5.3 Limestone: 7.5

(f) They could take more kick-net samples at each stream and average them.

(g) Limestone is a base so it neutralizes the acid rain and raises the pH of the stream. The granite streams are more polluted so their pH is lower.

(h) They should put catalytic converters on the power plant smokestacks. The catalytic converters would turn the sulfur dioxide into oxygen and water, so it would not make acid rain anymore.

How it scored

0/1a — Stream pH is something the students measured, so it is an outcome rather than the independent variable. The factor they chose to compare was bedrock type.
1/1b — The number of mayfly nymphs is a correct dependent variable, since it was counted at every stream.
1/1c — A testable, directional hypothesis that links bedrock type to an outcome the students actually measured.
0/1d — "Fair" does not say what is being controlled. The answer needed to name timing, weather or the snowmelt pulse as a factor that could otherwise cause the differences.
0/1e — Both values are correct, but no setup is shown. Readers usually require the work for a calculation point, so bare answers like these would likely earn nothing on the real exam. Always write out the numbers you add and the number you divide by (0).
1/1f — Names a specific, useful change to the method: several kick-net samples per stream, averaged. Adding one sentence on why averaging helps would make the point safer.
1/2g — Describing limestone as a base that neutralizes the acid earns the buffering point (1). Calling the granite streams "more polluted" contradicts the prompt, which says all eight streams receive similar deposition, and the answer never states that granite lacks neutralizing minerals (0).
0/2h — No catalyst turns sulfur dioxide into oxygen and water, because the sulfur atoms must end up somewhere. Power plants do use catalytic units, called selective catalytic reduction, to cut NOx, but this answer aims the device at SO2. Scrubbers, low-sulfur coal or a switch to renewable power were needed (0 + 0).

Where points die

Swapping the independent and dependent variables, or naming a measured quantity like stream pH as the independent variable. Ask what the researchers chose or set before collecting data. That is the independent variable, such as the pH they set in each tank or the bedrock type of the streams they picked. Anything they recorded afterward is a dependent variable. In a field study, a measured value like pH can be an outcome even though it sounds like a cause.

Naming an organism or a topic as a variable, such as "the oysters" or "water quality". A variable has to be measurable. Add the quantity and the unit: "percentage of larvae with a complete shell", "mayfly nymphs per kick-net sample", or "dissolved oxygen in mg/L". If you cannot picture a number going into the data table, it is not a variable.

Giving a control group when the question asks for a controlled variable, or the other way around. A controlled variable is a condition held the same in every trial, such as temperature, food or sampling date. A control group is the baseline group that does not get the treatment, such as tanks at normal ocean pH. Read which term the part uses and answer that one.

Writing a prediction ("lower pH will reduce shell growth") when the part asks for a null hypothesis, or writing a hypothesis about something the study never measured. A null hypothesis states no effect or no difference: "Seawater pH has no effect on shell formation." Any hypothesis must use the study's real variables. "Limestone streams will be healthier" cannot be tested, but "limestone streams will have more mayfly nymphs per sample" can.

Explaining ocean acidification only as "the acid dissolves the shells", or saying soft-bodied animals and marine mammals are hit hardest. Dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid, and its hydrogen ions bind carbonate ions to make bicarbonate. With less carbonate, corals, mollusks and calcifying plankton struggle to build calcium carbonate shells and skeletons. Water very low in carbonate can also dissolve existing shells, so dissolution is real, but it is incomplete when a question asks why shells fail to form. Jellyfish do not build these structures, and whales and dolphins breathe air, so neither is the group most directly harmed.

Proposing a fix that is vague or chemically impossible, such as catalytic converters that turn SO2 or CO2 into oxygen. Atoms do not disappear, so a pollutant has to be captured, prevented or swapped out. For sulfur, scrubbers trap SO2 with lime before it leaves the stack, and low-sulfur coal or renewable power prevents it. No catalyst removes SO2, but power plants do use selective catalytic reduction to cut NOx, which is another acid-deposition precursor. Match your device to the right pollutant, and always say how it cuts that pollutant.

Score your own response

0 / 10

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.