Which strategy most directly addresses the 'carbon budget' concept — the total amount of CO₂ humanity can still emit while keeping warming below 1.5°C?
- ASwitching from coal to natural gas to halve emissions while maintaining energy capacity.
- BIncreasing reforestation worldwide to remove sufficient CO₂ to offset current emissions completely.
- CDeveloping more efficient fossil fuel extraction technology to reduce energy waste.
- DRapidly transitioning to zero-carbon energy sources (solar, wind, nuclear) and deploying carbon dioxide removal (CDR) technologies.Correct
Why D is right
The carbon budget concept means the total cumulative CO₂ emissions cannot exceed a fixed amount to stay below a temperature target. At current emission rates, the remaining 1.5°C budget will be exhausted within years. Addressing it requires: (1) rapidly eliminating emissions (transitioning to zero-carbon energy) and (2) removing already-emitted CO₂ through CDR. These approaches must work in tandem — neither alone is sufficient.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Switching to natural gas reduces emissions ~50% compared to coal for the same energy, but a 50% reduction is far from zero and would still exhaust the 1.5°C carbon budget, just more slowly. The carbon budget requires approaching zero emissions, not halving them.
- B
- Incorrect. Reforestation is valuable but insufficient to offset current annual emissions (~37 billion tons CO₂/year). Global forests absorb about 2.6 billion tons/year net. Reforestation alone cannot close the gap, and forests are also threatened by the very climate change they are meant to mitigate.
- C
- Incorrect. More efficient fossil fuel extraction still produces CO₂ emissions. Efficiency improvements slow the rate of budget depletion but do not address the fundamental need to stop adding CO₂ to the atmosphere.