Which of the following best explains why coral reefs are sometimes described as 'biodiversity hotspots' but are also among the most threatened ecosystems on Earth?
- ACoral reefs have low biodiversity but high economic value, making them targets for overexploitation.
- BCoral reefs are biodiversity hotspots because they produce more NPP than any other marine ecosystem, making them magnets for fishing fleets.
- CCoral reefs support extraordinary species richness because of complex habitat structure and symbiotic relationships, but they are threatened by warming oceans (bleaching), acidification, and destructive fishing practices.Correct
- DCoral reefs are threatened primarily by invasive species that outcompete native corals for substrate space.
Why C is right
Coral reefs contain approximately 25% of all marine species despite covering less than 1% of the ocean floor — a remarkable biodiversity concentration. This biodiversity is supported by the physical complexity of reef structure (providing niches), symbiotic relationships (coral-zooxanthellae mutualism), and efficient nutrient recycling. However, reefs are now threatened by: (1) ocean warming causing coral bleaching (expulsion of symbiotic zooxanthellae); (2) ocean acidification (CO2 dissolution making it harder for corals to build calcium carbonate skeletons); (3) destructive fishing (cyanide, dynamite), overfishing, and coastal development.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Coral reefs are actually among the highest-biodiversity ecosystems on Earth (not low biodiversity); the threats are primarily environmental (climate change, acidification) and fishing-related, not just economic targeting.
- B
- Coral reefs have relatively low NPP per unit area despite their biodiversity (Darwin's Paradox); they are not major fishing grounds for large commercial fisheries; their biodiversity stems from habitat complexity and trophic structure, not high production.
- D
- Invasive species (like the crown-of-thorns starfish outbreaks and invasive algae) do threaten some reefs, but the primary global threats to coral reefs are ocean warming (bleaching) and acidification from climate change, not invasive species.