Skip to content
AP Environmental Science · Populations

Maximum sustainable yield

Maximum sustainable yield appears in 12 reviewed AP Environmental Science questions and sits in Populations. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Maximum sustainable yield is tested

Example 1Easier
A fishery biologist determines that a cod population in the North Atlantic has a carrying capacity of 200,000 metric tons. To achieve maximum sustainable yield, the population should be maintained at approximately what level?
  1. A150,000 metric tons
  2. B200,000 metric tons
  3. C50,000 metric tons
  4. D100,000 metric tonsCorrect

Why D is right

Maximum sustainable yield (MSY) is achieved when the population is at K/2, or half the carrying capacity. At 100,000 metric tons (K/2 = 200,000/2), the population has the highest rate of growth and can sustain the largest harvest without declining.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect. At 150,000 metric tons (3K/4), the population is above the optimal level. Growth rate is slower due to density-dependent limitations, yielding less surplus for harvest.
B
Incorrect. At carrying capacity (200,000 metric tons), the population growth rate is essentially zero. No sustainable harvest is possible because the population is not producing surplus.
C
Incorrect. At 50,000 metric tons (K/4), the population is below the optimal level for maximum sustainable yield. While per-capita growth rate is high, total production is less than at K/2.
Example 2Harder
A wildlife manager uses the logistic growth model to determine the maximum sustainable yield (MSY) for a deer population with K = 2,000 and r_max = 0.3 per year. What is the MSY (maximum number of deer that can be harvested annually without causing population decline)?
  1. A150 deerCorrect
  2. B100 deer
  3. C300 deer
  4. D50 deer

Why A is right

Maximum sustainable yield occurs at N = K/2 = 1,000 deer. MSY = (r_max x K) / 4 = (0.3 x 2,000) / 4 = 600 / 4 = 150 deer per year. This is the maximum number that can be sustainably harvested while maintaining the population at its most productive level.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect. 100 deer would result from an incorrect formula application, perhaps dividing by 6 instead of 4.
C
Incorrect. 300 deer would be r_max x K / 2 = 0.3 x 1,000, which equals the maximum growth rate at K/2 but does not correctly calculate MSY using the formula MSY = r_max x K / 4.
D
Incorrect. 50 deer would be far below the MSY, leaving unharvested growth potential. This would correspond to a much smaller K or lower r_max.
Example 3Medium
Global fish stocks have declined significantly since the mid-20th century. Which management strategy is most effective at allowing depleted fish populations to recover?
  1. AIncreasing the mesh size of fishing nets to allow juvenile fish to escape and reach reproductive age
  2. BConcentrating fishing effort on a single target species to allow all other species to recover
  3. CFishing moratoriums in depleted areas with catch limits set below maximum sustainable yieldCorrect
  4. DStocking depleted oceans with farm-raised fish from aquaculture facilities

Why C is right

The most effective recovery strategy combines temporary moratoriums (complete fishing bans) in severely depleted areas with science-based management that sets catch limits below the maximum sustainable yield (MSY). This allows fish populations to rebuild their breeding stock and age structure. Successful examples include the recovery of North Atlantic swordfish and Alaskan pollock under such management.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect. While increasing mesh size is a useful management tool that reduces bycatch of juveniles, it alone is insufficient to recover severely depleted stocks. It must be combined with overall catch reductions.
B
Incorrect. Concentrating fishing on one species can drive that species to collapse and does not address ecosystem-wide overfishing problems. Ecosystem-based fisheries management considers impacts on all species.
D
Incorrect. Stocking oceans with farm-raised fish can introduce diseases, parasites, and genetic problems to wild populations. It does not address the root cause of overfishing and can create ecological complications.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Populations.