Acid rain has which of the following primary effects on forest ecosystems?
- AIt primarily affects only aquatic ecosystems, while forest soils buffer all acid inputs without lasting damage.
- BIt leaches calcium, magnesium, and other essential nutrients from soils, weakens trees, and directly damages leaves, making forests more vulnerable to disease and insects.Correct
- CIt increases soil pH, making conditions unfavorable for acid-sensitive conifer trees.
- DIt fertilizes forests by providing sulfur and nitrogen that are essential plant nutrients.
Why B is right
Acid rain harms forests through multiple mechanisms: (1) Acidification of soil solution leaches positively charged nutrient cations (Ca2+, Mg2+, K+) from soils, depleting essential nutrients; (2) Acid mobilizes aluminum (Al3+) from soil minerals, which is toxic to plant roots and inhibits calcium uptake; (3) Direct damage to leaf waxy coatings (cuticles) impairs photosynthesis and increases susceptibility to frost and disease; (4) Acidification of surface waters kills fish and aquatic food sources for songbirds. The Black Forest decline in Germany ('Waldsterben') in the 1980s was partly attributed to acid deposition.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Forest ecosystems are significantly harmed by acid rain; while well-buffered soils can absorb some acid input, poorly buffered soils (on granite and gneiss) experience nutrient depletion and aluminum toxicity; forest decline in acid rain-affected regions is well-documented.
- C
- Acid rain decreases (not increases) soil pH; many forests in the eastern U.S. and Europe have experienced significant soil acidification from decades of acid deposition; this acidification, not increased pH, harms acid-sensitive species.
- D
- While sulfur and nitrogen are plant nutrients in appropriate forms and quantities, acid rain delivers them in acidic forms (H2SO4, HNO3) that acidify soils, mobilize toxic aluminum, and leach beneficial nutrients — the overall effect is harmful, not fertilizing.