The table shows hypothetical data on how often the leaders of one country, in official foreign-policy speeches, described five other countries with labels such as 'rogue state' or 'outlaw regime,' and whether the speaking country intervened militarily in each country in Year 5.
| Country | Label mentions, Year 1 | Label mentions, Year 4 | Military intervention in Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Atria | 40 | 42 | No |
| Belcora | 3 | 51 | Yes |
| Cendra | 2 | 1 | Yes |
| Dovania | 35 | 6 | No |
| Estmark | 4 | 38 | No |
A political geographer argues that labeling places as dangerous builds geographic imaginaries that make military action against them seem justified. Which country's data provide the strongest support for this argument?
- AAtria, because label use stayed high in both Year 1 and Year 4
- BDovania, because it was labeled often in Year 1 yet saw no intervention
- CCendra, because an intervention occurred though labels were almost never used
- DBelcora, because label use rose sharply in the years before an interventionCorrect
- EEstmark, because its label count rose by more than 30 mentions over the period
Why D is right
The argument is a critical-geopolitics claim: political language that casts places as threats helps make intervention seem justified. Supporting it requires a row where label use grows and an intervention then follows. Only Belcora fits. Its label mentions rose from 3 in Year 1 to 51 in Year 4, and the table shows an intervention in Year 5. Atria and Dovania were labeled heavily without any intervention. Estmark's labels rose with no intervention. Cendra faced an intervention without being labeled. None of these rows ties the labeling to the intervention.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Atria was labeled often in both years, but the table shows no intervention, so high label use alone did not lead to military action. This row does not support the argument.
- C
- Cendra was hardly ever labeled and was still the target of an intervention, so labeling cannot explain that intervention. This row weakens the argument.
- E
- Estmark's label count did rise sharply, but the table shows no intervention, so the row does not link labeling to military action. Choosing it looks only at the label trend and skips the outcome column.
- B
- Dovania was labeled often early on, but no intervention followed. Choosing it treats an early high count as evidence without checking the outcome column.