The following is a practice passage about a fictional country.
The coastal region of Alvesca, in a fictional country, has its own language, an elected parliament, a regional police force, and an autonomy statute that lets it collect most of its own taxes. When the regional parliament scheduled a vote on leaving the country, the national constitutional court declared the vote void. The court cited a clause stating that the national territory is indivisible and that its borders may be changed only through a referendum held across the entire country. Regional leaders replied that the people of Alvesca alone should decide Alvesca's future. Polls show the region's residents nearly evenly divided, with support for leaving concentrated among those who speak Alvescan at home.
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the passage?
- AAlvesca's push for independence is driven mainly by complaints that the region sends far more tax revenue to the capital than it receives back
- BThe court ruled the vote void because a change to the national territory requires the consent of voters across the whole country, not only those in the regionCorrect
- CThe national government responded to the scheduled vote by sending its armed forces to take control of the regional police and parliament
- DA clear majority of Alvesca's residents favor leaving the country, so a legal vote on independence would almost certainly pass
- EAlvesca's autonomy statute grants it very few powers of its own, which explains why its leaders now seek full independence
Why B is right
The passage says the court voided the vote by citing a clause that the national territory is indivisible and that borders can change only through a referendum held across the entire country. That is choice B. The court treats the whole nation, not the region alone, as the body that decides on secession. This is the tension between a region's claim to self-determination (the regional leaders say Alvesca alone should decide) and the constitutional framework of the sovereign state, the same tension seen in real devolution conflicts such as Catalonia's.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Fiscal grievances drive some real separatist movements, but the passage never says Alvesca sends surplus revenue to the capital. It says only that the region collects most of its own taxes, so this claim goes beyond the source.
- C
- Central governments have sometimes used force against separatists, but the passage describes only a court ruling. It mentions no military action against the regional police or parliament.
- D
- This misreads the polling. The passage says residents are nearly evenly divided, so it does not support a clear majority or a certain result.
- E
- This reverses the passage. Alvesca has its own parliament, police force, and power to collect most of its taxes, which is substantial autonomy, not very little.
Read the following practice passage.
Within a large European state lies a region with its own language and its own elected parliament. Control over schooling and language policy passed to the region decades ago, and that arrangement is no longer disputed. Last year the regional parliament organized a vote on whether the region should become a separate country, and a majority of those voting, concentrated in the port capital, chose separation. Leaders of the movement insist the new country would remain inside the continental trade union. The national constitutional court ruled the vote void, stating that the constitution recognizes one indivisible nation, and national officials refused to negotiate over the result.
Which of the following best describes the central conflict in the region, as presented in the passage?
- ARural districts in the interior are seeking to separate from the port capital, whose voters dominate the regional parliament.
- BThe regional parliament claims the right to decide the region's political status, while the national court treats the state's territory as indivisible.Correct
- CThe region's leaders want to leave the continental trade union, while national leaders want the entire state to remain a member of it.
- DNational officials are imposing the state language in the region's schools, while regional leaders defend instruction in their own language.
- ENational officials refuse to return more tax revenue to the region, while the regional parliament demands control over its own budget.
Why B is right
The passage centers on two opposing actions. The regional parliament held a vote on whether the region should become a separate country, which is a claim to self-determination by a subnational group. The national constitutional court voided that vote because the constitution recognizes one indivisible nation, which is the state's commitment to its territorial integrity. The passage rules out the other conflicts: language policy is settled, the movement wants to stay in the trade union, the port capital supported separation, and taxes are never mentioned. This is the same tension seen in real devolutionary movements such as Catalonia's in Spain.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Reverses the passage: support for separation was concentrated in the port capital, and the passage describes no move by interior districts to break away from it. The urban-rural pattern is a misreading of the vote, not the conflict itself.
- C
- Contradicted by the passage: the movement's leaders insist the new country would stay inside the continental trade union, so the dispute is not about leaving a supranational body.
- D
- Contradicted by the passage: control over schooling and language policy passed to the region decades ago and is no longer disputed. Language conflict often drives devolution, but not in this case.
- E
- Not supported: the passage never mentions taxes, revenue, or budgets. Fiscal grievances drive some devolution movements, but nothing in this source points to one.