A 50 kg climber ascends a 30 m cliff face in 10 min. Another climber (75 kg) climbs the same height in 15 min. Which climber develops more average power against gravity? (Use g = 10 m/s^2.)
- AClimber 2 (75 kg, 15 min), because she has more mass.
- BBoth climbers develop equal power.Correct
- CClimber 1 develops more power because power = mgh/t and 50*30/600 > 75*30/900.
- DClimber 1 (50 kg, 10 min), because she climbs faster.
Why B is right
P_1 = mgh/t = 50*10*30/600 = 15,000/600 = 25 W. P_2 = 75*10*30/900 = 22,500/900 = 25 W. Both climbers develop exactly 25 W of average power against gravity. The result follows from conservation of energy or the work-energy relationship, so the change in kinetic or potential energy sets the answer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because greater mass alone does not mean greater power; it depends on the rate of climbing as well.
- C
- Incorrect in its conclusion; the numerical comparison shows they are equal (both = 25 W), not unequal.
- D
- Incorrect because while Climber 1 climbs faster (3 m/min vs. 2 m/min), the larger mass of Climber 2 exactly compensates, yielding equal power.