Skip to content
AP Physics 1 · Work, Energy, and Power

Comparison

Comparison appears in 7 reviewed AP Physics 1 questions and sits in Work, Energy, and Power. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Comparison is tested

Example 1Harder
A 50 kg climber ascends a 30 m cliff face in 10 min. Another climber (75 kg) climbs the same height in 15 min. Which climber develops more average power against gravity? (Use g = 10 m/s^2.)
  1. AClimber 2 (75 kg, 15 min), because she has more mass.
  2. BBoth climbers develop equal power.Correct
  3. CClimber 1 develops more power because power = mgh/t and 50*30/600 > 75*30/900.
  4. DClimber 1 (50 kg, 10 min), because she climbs faster.

Why B is right

P_1 = mgh/t = 50*10*30/600 = 15,000/600 = 25 W. P_2 = 75*10*30/900 = 22,500/900 = 25 W. Both climbers develop exactly 25 W of average power against gravity. The result follows from conservation of energy or the work-energy relationship, so the change in kinetic or potential energy sets the answer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because greater mass alone does not mean greater power; it depends on the rate of climbing as well.
C
Incorrect in its conclusion; the numerical comparison shows they are equal (both = 25 W), not unequal.
D
Incorrect because while Climber 1 climbs faster (3 m/min vs. 2 m/min), the larger mass of Climber 2 exactly compensates, yielding equal power.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Work, Energy, and Power.