A solid sphere (I = (2/5)MR^2) and a solid cylinder (I = (1/2)MR^2) of the same mass and radius start from rest and roll without slipping down the same incline. Which reaches the bottom first?
- AThe solid sphere, because its smaller rotational inertia leaves more energy for translation.Correct
- BThe solid cylinder, because its larger moment of inertia gives it more angular momentum.
- CThey reach the bottom at the same time because they have the same mass and radius.
- DThe solid cylinder, because it has less rotational inertia than the sphere.
Why A is right
When rolling without slipping, the object with a smaller moment of inertia (relative to MR^2) converts a larger fraction of gravitational PE to translational KE. The sphere (I = 0.4MR^2) has a smaller moment of inertia than the cylinder (I = 0.5MR^2), so the sphere reaches the bottom first.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. A larger moment of inertia means more energy is stored as rotational KE, leaving less for translational KE. This makes the cylinder slower, not faster.
- C
- Incorrect. Although they have the same mass and radius, their different mass distributions lead to different moments of inertia and different translational accelerations.
- D
- Incorrect. The cylinder has a larger moment of inertia (0.5MR^2) than the sphere (0.4MR^2), so more of its energy goes to rotation, making it slower.