A spinning top has an angular momentum of 0.8 kg*m^2/s. If a torque of 0.2 N*m is applied to slow it down, how long does it take to stop?
- A0.4 s
- B16 s
- C1.6 s
- D4.0 sCorrect
Why D is right
A net torque changes angular momentum at a rate equal to the torque: τ = ΔL/Δt. To stop, the top must lose all 0.8 kg·m²/s of its angular momentum, so ΔL = 0.8 kg·m²/s. Solving for time gives Δt = ΔL/τ = (0.8 kg·m²/s)/(0.2 N·m) = 4.0 s, which is choice D.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- 0.4 s is one tenth of the correct time. It comes from a decimal-place slip, such as treating the angular momentum as 0.08 kg·m²/s, so 0.08/0.2 = 0.4 s. The units also show this is wrong, because (kg·m²/s)/(N·m) = s and the correct ratio 0.8/0.2 gives 4.0 s.
- B
- 16 s comes from squaring the ratio, (L/τ)² = (0.8/0.2)² = 16. The angular impulse relation τΔt = ΔL is linear in time, so nothing should be squared.
- C
- 1.6 s comes from combining L and τ by multiplication instead of division (0.8 × 0.2 = 0.16) and then shifting the decimal. Multiplying angular momentum by torque does not give units of seconds; time is ΔL divided by τ.