A researcher studying language and learning places a 3-year-old child and a 30-year-old adult in separate environments where an artificial language is spoken. After two weeks of immersion, the child speaks the artificial language far more fluently than the adult, despite the adult having superior prior language knowledge and general intelligence. This finding most directly supports:
- AThe Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, which predicts that young children are free of prior linguistic constraints
- BOperant conditioning principles, because children receive more reinforcement for correct utterances
- CThe concept of a biological critical period during which language acquisition is maximally efficientCorrect
- DObservational learning theory, because children imitate speech more readily than adults
Why C is right
The critical period hypothesis (associated with Lenneberg and supported by Chomsky's nativist theory) proposes that language is most easily acquired during early childhood due to neural plasticity and the operation of an innate language acquisition device (LAD). As the brain matures and the critical period closes (around puberty), second-language acquisition becomes progressively more difficult, even with greater cognitive resources.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Sapir-Whorf hypothesis concerns whether language shapes thought; it does not predict age-based differences in language acquisition speed.
- B
- While children do receive reinforcement for speech, operant conditioning alone cannot explain the dramatic advantage children have; adults receive operant input in language learning contexts too.
- D
- Adults also imitate speech in immersion contexts; the difference is not in imitation capacity but in the neurological substrate that enables rapid acquisition.
Noam Chomsky's 1959 critique of Skinner's book 'Verbal Behavior' was significant in psychology because it:
- AEstablished that psychoanalytic concepts were necessary to explain the symbolic nature of human language
- BChallenged the behaviorist account of language by arguing for an innate language acquisition deviceCorrect
- CDemonstrated that behaviorism could account for the complexity of human language through chaining and shaping
- DProved that language is entirely learned through operant conditioning and positive reinforcement
Why B is right
Chomsky's influential critique argued that language is too structurally complex and too rapidly acquired by children to be explained by operant conditioning alone. He proposed an innate Language Acquisition Device (LAD) that prepares children to learn grammar. This challenge to behaviorism's explanatory scope was a major catalyst for the cognitive revolution's legitimization of mental processes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Chomsky's argument was cognitive-linguistic, not psychoanalytic; he proposed innate grammatical structures, not psychoanalytic symbolism.
- C
- Incorrect because Skinner tried to argue that language could be explained through chaining and shaping; Chomsky's critique specifically challenged the adequacy of this behaviorist explanation.
- D
- Incorrect because Chomsky argued the opposite — that operant conditioning cannot adequately explain language acquisition; he proposed innate linguistic structures.