- AA genetic disorder causes intellectual disability in all carriers regardless of environment, demonstrating that some traits are purely genetic
- BA child raised in an enriched educational environment scores 15 IQ points higher than expected based on parental IQ alone, showing that environment overrides genetics
- CTwo identical twins raised in different households both develop the same personality trait, demonstrating that genetics fully determines personality regardless of environment
- DA person inherits a gene variant associated with depression risk AND grows up in a highly stressful household, dramatically increasing their risk of developing depression compared to either factor aloneCorrect
Why D is right
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because this describes a genetic main effect (a genetic disorder that causes disability regardless of environment), which is the opposite of a gene-environment interaction; interactions specifically occur when environmental context modifies the genetic effect.
- B
- Incorrect because this shows a main effect of environment (enriched education raising IQ) but does not specifically demonstrate gene-environment interaction; an interaction would require showing that the environmental effect is different for different genotypes.
- C
- Incorrect because this example shows a main effect of genetics (twins agreeing despite different environments) but does not demonstrate gene-environment interaction; an interaction requires that the genetic effect differs depending on the environmental condition.