Skip to content
AP Psychology · Mental and Physical Health

Scientific method

Scientific method appears in 21 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Mental and Physical Health. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The scientific method is the cycle psychologists use to test ideas against evidence. You start with a theory, turn it into a falsifiable hypothesis, operationalize each variable as something you can observe and measure, collect data, and then share the method so others can replicate it. That measure can be a count, a time or a score.

Why it matters

Every claim in this course, from how well a therapy works to how stress harms health, is only as strong as the study behind it. The method is how psychology tells real effects apart from hunches and lucky results.

How the exam tests it

Questions usually hand you a study and ask which choice shows one specific step. That might be an operational definition, such as "words written down from a 20-item list in 2 minutes," or a hypothesis that some result could prove wrong. Others describe a finding that failed when a second lab ran it, which points to the replication crisis.

Don’t confuse it with

Students mix up operationalizing a variable with replicating a study, but operationalizing defines how one variable is measured, while replicating means running the whole study again to see whether the result holds.

Scientific method in real questions

Example 1Easier
A psychologist plans an experiment to test whether students recall more words when they are tested in the same room where they learned the words than when they are tested in a different room. Which of the following best illustrates operationalization in this study?
  1. AShe repeats an earlier context-dependent memory experiment with a new sample of students to see whether its results hold
  2. BShe reads published studies on encoding specificity before writing her hypothesis
  3. CShe measures recall as the number of words from a 20-word list that participants write down in 2 minutesCorrect
  4. DShe picks memory as her topic because many students say they struggle on exams

Why C is right

Operationalization means defining an abstract variable in concrete, measurable terms so that it can be observed and the study can be replicated. In this context-dependent memory experiment (Unit 2, retrieving memories), the dependent variable is recall. Defining recall as the number of words from a 20-word list written down in 2 minutes turns the construct into a specific, countable measure. The other choices describe replication, a literature review, and choosing a topic, which are all research activities but none of them defines a variable.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because repeating an earlier experiment with new participants is replication. It checks whether findings generalize but does not define how a variable will be measured.
B
Incorrect because reviewing prior research on encoding specificity is part of building the hypothesis. It does not turn 'recall' into a concrete, measurable procedure.
D
Incorrect because choosing a topic for its practical relevance is the motivation for the research, not a measurable definition of any variable.
Example 2Medium
A social psychologist plans a study of conformity in which participants judge which of three lines matches a standard line after hearing several confederates answer first. Which of the following is the BEST example of a falsifiable hypothesis for this study?
  1. APeople who go along with a group are, deep down, searching for something that will make them feel whole
  2. BEvery response a person gives in a group, whether agreeing or disagreeing with the others, ultimately reflects a hidden unconscious need to belong and to be accepted by them
  3. CParticipants who answer aloud after four confederates give a wrong answer will make more errors than participants who answer privately in writingCorrect
  4. DSome people possess an inner social energy that draws them toward agreeing with others

Why C is right

A falsifiable hypothesis is stated so that observation could, in principle, show it is wrong. Choice C names operationalized variables: answering publicly aloud versus privately in writing, and the number of errors on the line-judgment task. It also makes a directional prediction about conformity (Unit 4, Psychology of Social Situations). If the public and private groups made the same number of errors, or the private group made more, the data would disconfirm it. The other choices rely on vague, unmeasurable, or all-explaining claims that no result could refute.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
This is not falsifiable because 'deep down' and 'something that will make them feel whole' are vague and not operationalized. No observable result in the line-judgment task could show the claim is wrong.
B
This is not falsifiable because the claim fits every possible outcome. Agreeing and disagreeing are both said to reflect the same hidden need, so no data could contradict it. Students often mistake a claim that explains everything for a strong one.
D
This is not falsifiable because an 'inner social energy' cannot be measured. No empirical test could disprove that such an energy exists, even though the claim sounds as if it is about conformity.
Example 3Harder
A psychology study concludes that a new therapy is effective (p < .05). A replication attempt by an independent lab finds p = .48 using the same protocol. Which contemporary issue in psychology does this best illustrate?
  1. AThe replication crisis, reflecting widespread concerns that many psychological findings do not hold up when independently testedCorrect
  2. BPublication bias, because journals prefer publishing negative results that challenge prior findings
  3. CDemand characteristics in the original study, because participants guessed the purpose and inflated results
  4. DType II error in the replication study, because the independent lab failed to reject a false null hypothesis

Why A is right

The replication crisis refers to the widespread finding that a significant proportion of published psychological studies fail to replicate when attempted by independent researchers. This has prompted major reforms in research practices, including pre-registration, larger samples, and open data sharing.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because publication bias refers to journals preferring positive (significant) results, which would cause the original significant finding to be published; publication bias would make replication failures less visible, not more.
C
Incorrect because demand characteristics are a concern in the original study's design, not the explanation for a broader pattern of replication failures across psychology.
D
Incorrect because a Type II error is possible, but the question asks what issue this best illustrates at a broader level; the pattern of failed replications across psychology defines the replication crisis.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Mental and Physical Health.