Skip to content
AP Psychology · Development and Learning

Higher order conditioning

Higher order conditioning appears in 3 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Development and Learning. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Higher-order (second-order) conditioning happens when a stimulus that is already a conditioned stimulus is paired with a new neutral stimulus, so the new stimulus also starts to trigger the conditioned response. The new stimulus is never paired with the original unconditioned stimulus.

Why it matters

It explains how fears and likes spread to things that were never linked to the original cause. A child afraid of a dentist's drill can come to fear the dentist's white coat and office smell, because those cues were paired with the drill, not with pain.

How the exam tests it

Stems give a two-step story and ask what the second fear is called. To spot it, check that the new cue was paired only with an earlier CS, which acts like a UCS in the second round of learning.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse it with stimulus generalization, but generalization is a response to a cue that looks or sounds like the CS, while higher-order conditioning needs a separate pairing of the new cue with the CS.

Higher order conditioning in real questions

Example 1Harder
A child first learns to fear a dentist's drill after associating it with pain. Later, the child develops fear of the dentist's white coat and office smell simply through their association with the drill. The child's fear of the white coat, which was never directly paired with pain, is an example of:
  1. AStimulus generalization, because the white coat is similar in appearance to other medical stimuli that have been paired with pain
  2. BExtinction, because the original fear of pain has spread to new stimuli, creating additional fear responses
  3. CHigher-order conditioning, because a new neutral stimulus (white coat) has been paired with an already-established conditioned stimulus (drill) to produce a conditioned responseCorrect
  4. DReconditioning, because the white coat stimulus has been reconditioned to elicit fear through its new association with the dental drill

Why C is right

Higher-order (second-order) conditioning occurs when a well-established CS (the drill) is used as the UCS to condition a new neutral stimulus (white coat/smell). The white coat was never paired with pain (the original UCS), but was paired with the drill (CS1), which already elicited fear (CR). This second pairing makes the white coat a CS2 that elicits fear without ever having been directly paired with pain.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because stimulus generalization involves responding to stimuli that physically resemble the original CS, not to stimuli that have been associated with the CS. The white coat is associated with the drill through a temporal/spatial relationship, not physical similarity to pain or the drill.
B
Incorrect because extinction refers to the weakening of a conditioned response through repeated CS-alone presentations, not the spread of fear to new stimuli. The fear has expanded, not diminished, which is more consistent with higher-order conditioning and generalization.
D
Incorrect because reconditioning is not a standard classical conditioning term for this process. The child is not being conditioned again from scratch — rather, an already-learned CS is being used to condition a new stimulus, which is the specific process of higher-order conditioning.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Development and Learning.