Skip to content
AP Psychology · Development and Learning

Instinctive drift

Instinctive drift appears in 3 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Development and Learning. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Instinctive drift is the tendency of a trained animal to slide back toward its natural, species-typical behavior, even though that behavior costs it the reward. Keller and Marian Breland described it in 1961 after their trained animals kept "misbehaving."

Why it matters

It shows that biology limits operant conditioning, so you cannot shape any behavior you like with enough reinforcement. A raccoon trained to drop coins into a box for food began rubbing and dipping the coins, as raccoons do with food.

How the exam tests it

Stems describe a trained animal whose learned trick breaks down into food-related habits and ask which principle this shows. The answer is the idea of biological constraints on learning, with the Brelands as the researchers.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse it with extinction, but in extinction a behavior fades because reinforcement stops, while in instinctive drift the reward is still given and an inborn behavior pushes the trained one aside.

Instinctive drift in real questions

Example 1Harder
The Brelands trained a raccoon to pick up coins and deposit them in a metal container for a food reward. Over time, the raccoon began to rub the coins together and dip them in the container repeatedly before releasing them, mimicking food-washing behavior. This behavior, called instinctive drift, best illustrates which principle?
  1. ABiological preparedness, because the raccoon was genetically predisposed to learn food-related behaviors more easily than arbitrary behaviors
  2. BSpontaneous recovery, because the raccoon's natural behaviors reappeared after a period during which they had been suppressed through training
  3. CExtinction, because the reinforcement contingency was no longer effectively maintaining the trained coin-depositing behavior
  4. DInstinctive drift, because the animal's trained behavior was replaced by species-typical behaviors related to food, despite operant trainingCorrect

Why D is right

Instinctive drift, described by Keller and Marian Breland, refers to the tendency of animals to drift back toward instinctive, species-typical behaviors during training, despite operant conditioning. As the raccoon's trained behavior (depositing coins) became associated with food, the raccoon's innate food-handling instincts (rubbing and washing objects before eating) began to intrude. This demonstrates that biological constraints can limit the power of operant conditioning.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because biological preparedness (Garcia's work) refers to the predisposition to form certain associations more easily than others, particularly taste-illness associations. While related to biological constraints, it specifically describes ease of CS-UCS association formation, not the replacement of learned behaviors with instinctive ones.
B
Incorrect because spontaneous recovery refers to the return of an extinguished classically conditioned response after a rest period — not the emergence of species-typical behaviors during active operant training.
C
Incorrect because extinction involves the weakening of a behavior when the reinforcer is removed. In instinctive drift, food reinforcement was still being provided — it was the biological pull of instinctive behaviors, not the absence of reinforcement, that disrupted the trained behavior.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Development and Learning.