- B
- Incorrect because the experiment's conclusion was not about punishment effectiveness in general — it was specifically about the effects of controllability. The dogs that received the same amount of shock but could escape it did not show helplessness, demonstrating that inescapability (lack of control), not shock per se, produced the helplessness.
- C
- Incorrect because shock intensity was not the variable that distinguished helpless from non-helpless dogs. Control group dogs that received equivalent escapable shocks did try to escape in the new shuttle box, disproving the intensity explanation.
- D
- Incorrect because classical conditioning of contextual fear would predict avoidance or escape attempts, not passivity. The dogs' failure to try to escape represents learned passivity from uncontrollability, which is an operant/cognitive phenomenon, not classical fear conditioning.