Skip to content
AP Psychology · Development and Learning

Partial reinforcement extinction effect

Partial reinforcement extinction effect appears in 4 reviewed AP Psychology questions and sits in Development and Learning. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The partial reinforcement extinction effect is the finding that behaviors reinforced only some of the time are harder to extinguish than behaviors reinforced every time. Variable schedules, especially variable ratio, are the most resistant to extinction.

Why it matters

It explains why intermittent rewards, like slot machine payouts, build habits that last. It also explains why giving in to a child only now and then makes whining harder to stop.

How the exam tests it

A stem trains pigeons on variable ratio versus fixed ratio schedules, then stops all food. The variable ratio group keeps pecking longest because long runs without food were already normal, so the pigeons cannot easily tell reinforcement has ended.

Don’t confuse it with

Students assume continuous reinforcement builds the strongest habit; it makes learning fastest, but behavior learned that way extinguishes fastest because the missing reward is noticed right away.

Partial reinforcement extinction effect in real questions

Example 1Medium
A researcher trains pigeons to peck a key for food using continuous reinforcement, then switches to a variable ratio schedule for half the group and a fixed ratio schedule for the other half. When the researcher stops delivering food for all pigeons, which group will most likely continue pecking the longest?
  1. AThe fixed ratio group, because the predictability of the reinforcement schedule makes each food delivery more rewarding and motivating
  2. BBoth groups will extinguish at the same rate, because the total number of reinforcements received determines resistance to extinction equally
  3. CThe variable ratio group, because unpredictable reinforcement makes it harder to detect that reinforcement has stoppedCorrect
  4. DThe continuous reinforcement group, because they received the most total reinforcements, which should build the strongest response tendency

Why C is right

The variable ratio group will show greater resistance to extinction. Under a VR schedule, the pigeon pecks varying numbers of times before food arrives — sometimes 2, sometimes 20. When reinforcement stops during extinction, the VR pigeon cannot easily detect the change, because long response strings without food were already normal. In contrast, FR pigeons pecked predictable numbers before food arrived, so the absence of food is detected sooner. This is the partial reinforcement extinction effect.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because predictability in fixed ratio schedules does not increase resistance to extinction — it actually makes extinction more detectable. The FR pigeon has a clear expectation of when food should arrive and can more easily detect its absence.
B
Incorrect because substantial research demonstrates that VR schedules produce significantly greater resistance to extinction than FR schedules, which produce significantly greater resistance than continuous reinforcement. The schedule type, not total reinforcement count, is the key factor.
D
Incorrect because total reinforcements received do not determine resistance to extinction. Organisms on continuous reinforcement (which maximize reinforcements) actually extinguish fastest because they quickly detect when reinforcement stops, since they expect it after every response.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Development and Learning.