A principal at a high school with 1,200 students believes that fewer than 40% of the students eat breakfast at home on school days. She selects a random sample of 30 students, and 9 of them (p-hat = 0.30) say they eat breakfast at home on school days. She plans to test H0: p = 0.40 versus Ha: p < 0.40 and find the p-value from a normal model. Which statement correctly assesses the conditions for this test?
- AThe 10% condition is not met because 30 students is less than 10% of the 1,200 students, so the responses are not independent.
- BAll conditions are met: the sample is random, 30 is under 10% of 1,200, and expected counts 12 and 18 are at least 10.Correct
- CThe Random condition is not met because a sample of only 30 students is too small to represent a school of 1,200 students.
- DThe Large Counts condition is not met because only 9 students in the sample said yes, which is fewer than 10, so the normal-based p-value is not reliable.
Why B is right
For a significance test about a proportion, the Large Counts condition is checked with the null value p0 = 0.40, because the p-value is computed assuming H0 is true: 30(0.40) = 12 and 30(0.60) = 18, and both are at least 10. The sample is random, and n = 30 is less than 10% of the population (0.10 x 1,200 = 120), so treating the observations as independent is reasonable. Because all conditions are met, the normal-based p-value can be trusted: SE = sqrt(0.40(0.60)/30) ≈ 0.0894, z = (0.30 - 0.40)/0.0894 ≈ -1.12, and the p-value ≈ 0.13.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Gets the 10% condition backwards. The sample must be no more than 10% of the population, and 30 < 120, so the condition is satisfied, not violated.
- C
- Mixes up sample size with random selection. The Random condition is about how the sample was chosen. A random sample of 30 meets it no matter how large the school is.
- D
- Uses the observed count (n times p-hat = 9) to check Large Counts. For a test, the check uses the hypothesized p0, which gives expected counts 12 and 18, so the condition is met.