In a study examining whether a new fertilizer increases crop yield, the null hypothesis is H0: the new fertilizer has no effect on yield. A Type I error in this context would be:
- AUsing too small a sample size to detect a real effect.
- BApplying the fertilizer to the wrong type of crop.
- CConcluding the fertilizer has no effect when it actually does.
- DConcluding the fertilizer increases yield when it actually has no effect.Correct
Why D is right
A Type I error (false positive) is rejecting the null hypothesis when it is actually true. Here, the null hypothesis is that the fertilizer has no effect. A Type I error means concluding that the fertilizer works (rejecting H0) when in reality it has no effect on yield.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Using too small a sample size to detect a real effect relates to low statistical power, which increases the probability of a Type II error, not a Type I error.
- B
- Applying the fertilizer to the wrong crop is an experimental design error, not a Type I error in hypothesis testing.
- C
- Concluding the fertilizer has no effect when it actually does is a Type II error (false negative) — failing to reject H0 when H0 is false.
A quality control engineer wants to test whether the defect rate of a manufacturing process has decreased from the historical rate of 8%. She inspects 250 items and finds 12 defective. Which are the appropriate null and alternative hypotheses?
- AH0: p = 0.08, Ha: p ≠ 0.08
- BH0: p < 0.08, Ha: p = 0.08
- CH0: p = 0.08, Ha: p < 0.08Correct
- DH0: p = 0.048, Ha: p < 0.048
Why C is right
The null hypothesis should state the parameter equals the historical value: H0: p = 0.08. Because the engineer suspects the rate has decreased, the alternative hypothesis is one-sided: Ha: p < 0.08. The sample proportion of 12/250 = 0.048 is the observed statistic, not a hypothesis value.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the engineer specifically wants to test whether the rate has decreased, making this a one-sided test (Ha: p < 0.08), not a two-sided test (Ha: p ≠ 0.08).
- B
- Incorrect because the null hypothesis must contain the equality (H0: p = 0.08), and the alternative contains the inequality. The roles are reversed here.
- D
- Incorrect because the hypotheses should reference the historical rate of 0.08, not the sample proportion of 0.048. Hypotheses are statements about the population parameter, not the sample statistic.
A study examines whether a new tutoring program improves student test scores. Students are randomly assigned to tutoring or control. After the program, the tutoring group shows a 5-point improvement compared to the control group (p = 0.002). Which statement BEST interprets the p-value?
- AThe probability that tutoring improves test scores is 99.8%, given the observed 5-point difference between groups.
- BThere is a 0.2% probability that the null hypothesis of no tutoring effect is true, given the observed data.
- CThe tutoring program improves scores by 5 points in 99.8% of cases.
- DIf tutoring had no effect, there would be a 0.2% chance of seeing a difference of 5 points or more.Correct
Why D is right
The p-value is the probability of observing results as extreme as (or more extreme than) what was observed, ASSUMING the null hypothesis is true. P = 0.002 means that if tutoring truly had no effect, there would be only a 0.2% chance of seeing a 5-point or larger difference between groups by chance alone.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The p-value does not give the probability that the treatment works. It gives the probability of observed data under H0. These are fundamentally different.
- B
- P-values are not probabilities that H0 is true. In frequentist statistics, H0 is either true or not; the p-value describes data probability under H0, not the probability of H0 itself.
- C
- The p-value says nothing about how consistently the treatment produces the same improvement across individuals. It describes the probability of the observed aggregate outcome under the null.