Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Argument Essay

6 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The argument essay is the fourth and last question in Section II of the AP U.S. Government and Politics exam. Section II has four free-response questions: Concept Application (3 points), Quantitative Analysis (4 points), SCOTUS Comparison (4 points), and this Argument Essay (6 points). You get 100 minutes for all four, and the section is 50% of your exam score. The four questions are weighted equally, so this one essay is worth about 12.5% of your score. Plan on about 40 minutes for it.

On this page · 6 sections

The prompt names a debate about American government. It asks you to argue one side of it. Then it lists three of the nine foundational documents you studied: the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, Federalist No. 10, Brutus No. 1, the Constitution, Federalist No. 51, Federalist No. 70, Federalist No. 78, and the Letter from Birmingham Jail. At least one of your pieces of evidence must come from that list of three.

Readers score with a 6-point rubric. Each row is scored separately, but the rows build on your claim. Without a defensible claim you can usually earn only the 1-point evidence credit, because evidence, reasoning, and the rebuttal all have to support or answer a claim. - Claim (1 point): a defensible thesis that sets up a line of reasoning. - Evidence (up to 3 points): specific pieces of evidence that support your claim. The 2nd and 3rd points both need a piece from the listed documents. - Reasoning (1 point): you explain why your evidence proves your claim. - Alternative perspective (1 point): you answer the other side by refuting it, conceding part of it, or rebutting it.

Readers do not take points away for grammar, spelling, or an awkward sentence. They look for each skill. A factual error does not cost a point on its own. But a document you describe wrongly cannot count as evidence. That is a common way to lose evidence points.

The rubric, in plain terms

6 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Claim or thesis1 pt

Take one clear side on the question the prompt asks and give a reason that maps out your argument. For example, a thesis that presidential power has grown but still fits the Framers' design, because Congress's control of money and the courts still check it, earns the point. Saying there are good arguments on both sides does not, and neither does a restatement of the prompt. Put the claim in one place, normally the end of your first paragraph.

Evidence3 pts

1 point: you give one piece of accurate evidence that is relevant to the topic. 2 points: you use one specific piece of evidence from one of the three listed documents and tie it to your claim, not just to the topic. 3 points: you add a second specific piece that also backs your claim. A specific piece from outside the list, such as a court case, can earn the 1st point but cannot earn the 2nd on its own. Your second piece can be any other of the nine foundational documents, a required Supreme Court case, a law, an amendment, or a real event. Name it and say what it shows. A document you describe wrongly earns nothing, for example saying Federalist No. 51 argues for a single energetic president.

Reasoning1 pt

Explain HOW your evidence proves your claim, not just WHAT the evidence says. The test is a sentence built on the word because that links the two. For example: Because Federalist No. 70 wanted one person who could act fast, a president who sends troops in a crisis is doing what Hamilton designed. Ending a paragraph with a line such as this shows the president has too much power only restates the claim. It does not reason.

Response to an alternative perspective1 pt

Name a real opposing argument, then answer it in a way that fits your thesis. You can refute it (show it is wrong), concede part of it and explain why your claim still holds, or rebut it (answer it with a counterargument or counter-evidence that outweighs it). The answer must carry its own reasoning or evidence. Writing that some people disagree but you still think you are right earns nothing.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Presidential power and the Framers' design

Documents for this essay (draw on at least one): - Federalist No. 51 - Federalist No. 70 - The Constitution of the United States

  1. (Essay)Since the 1930s, presidents have taken on far more power. Take a position on whether that larger presidency still fits the plan of government the Framers built. In your essay: - Open with a thesis that takes a side someone could argue against, and that maps out how your essay will prove it. - Prove that thesis with at least two specific facts or documents. One has to be a document from the box above. For the other, pick any other foundational document or anything else you learned in the course. - For each one, explain why it makes your thesis true. - Take on the strongest view against yours and answer it.
Prompt 2

Keep the Electoral College or switch to a national popular vote

Documents for this essay (draw on at least one): - Federalist No. 10 - Brutus No. 1 - The Constitution of the United States

  1. (Essay)Take a position on whether a national popular vote should replace the Electoral College as the way the United States picks its president. In your essay: - Open with a thesis that takes a side someone could argue against, and that maps out how your essay will prove it. - Prove that thesis with at least two specific facts or documents. One has to be a document from the box above. For the other, pick any other foundational document or anything else you learned in the course. - For each one, explain why it makes your thesis true. - Take on the strongest view against yours and answer it.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Presidential power and the Framers' design · high-scoring response6/6

Presidents today do far more than the Framers pictured. They issue executive orders, make executive agreements, and send troops abroad without a declaration of war. Even so, this growth is consistent with the Framers' design. The Framers wanted a strong single executive who could act quickly. They also built checks that still limit that executive today.

First, Hamilton argued in Federalist No. 70 that good government needs an energetic executive. He wanted one president, not a council, so that someone could decide and act fast and the public would know who to blame. Modern events call for exactly that. After the attacks of September 11, 2001, President Bush had to respond within hours. Congress, with 535 members and two chambers, could not have acted within hours. When modern presidents act alone in a crisis, they are using the energy Hamilton designed the office to have. Because the Framers chose a single executive on purpose, presidential power growing in emergencies is the system working as planned, not breaking.

Second, the checks Madison described in Federalist No. 51 still limit presidents. Madison argued that each branch should use its own ambition to block the others, so each branch has tools to resist the rest. After Vietnam, Congress passed the War Powers Resolution in 1973. It requires the president to notify Congress within 48 hours of sending troops. It also requires the troops to come home within 60 days unless Congress approves, plus 30 days to withdraw. The Court also enforces the Constitution's structure. In Clinton v. City of New York (1998), it struck down the Line Item Veto Act. It ruled that even Congress cannot give the president power to cancel parts of a signed law, because the Constitution requires the president to sign or veto a bill as a whole. Congress also controls the budget, so a president cannot fund a program it refuses to pay for. These checks show that the other branches and the Constitution itself still put real limits on the president, just as Madison expected.

Critics argue that executive orders let presidents make policy without Congress, which the Framers never intended. It is true that orders skip the legislative process. In 2009, Obama's Executive Order 13492 ordered the prison at Guantanamo Bay closed without a vote in Congress. But Congress refused to fund moving the prisoners into the United States, so the prison stayed open. In 2018, Trump reversed the order with one of his own. Courts can strike orders down too, as the Court did to Truman's steel mill seizure in Youngstown v. Sawyer (1952). So executive orders are not a way around the system. They stay under the same checks that Federalist No. 51 relies on.

The presidency has grown, but it has grown inside the Framers' structure. The energy came from Federalist No. 70 and the limits came from Federalist No. 51.

How it scored

1/1claim — The last two sentences of the opening paragraph take a clear side (consistent with the design). They also set up the two-part line of reasoning: energy by design, checks still working.
3/3evidence — Two listed documents are described accurately and used to back the claim. Federalist No. 70 supports the case for a single energetic executive. Federalist No. 51 is backed by specific limits: the War Powers Resolution with correct details, and Clinton v. City of New York, where the Court held that the Constitution's structure blocks a line-item veto. Either document alone, with its supporting detail, would count as a specific piece.
1/1reasoning — The sentence explaining that the Framers chose a single executive on purpose shows why emergency action fits the design. The second paragraph explains why limits from Congress, the Court, and the budget show the checks working.
1/1rebuttal — The response concedes that executive orders skip Congress and gives a real one, Obama's Guantanamo order. It then rebuts the point with evidence: Congress blocked the order with its funding power, the next president reversed it, and courts can strike orders down, as in Youngstown. The rebuttal stays consistent with the thesis.
Presidential power and the Framers' design · mid-scoring response3/6

Presidential power has grown way beyond what the Framers wanted, because presidents now take the country to war and set policy without Congress, so it is not consistent with their design.

The Constitution says that Congress has the power to declare war. But presidents have sent troops into a lot of wars without Congress ever declaring war. This shows presidents have too much power now.

Also, in Federalist 51 Hamilton said that the country needed a single, energetic president who could act with speed. But the Framers would not want presidents to have this much power today. This shows that the presidency is not what they designed.

Presidents also get their way by going public. This is when the president meets with members of Congress in their home districts to convince them to vote for his bills. This gives presidents even more power over Congress, which the Framers did not plan.

Some people say that presidents need more power to deal with emergencies like wars and terrorism. But presidents still have too much power and it goes against the Constitution.

In the end, the president has become much stronger than the Framers designed and the system is out of balance.

How it scored

1/1claim — The first sentence takes a defensible side (not consistent). It gives a real reason: presidents now go to war and set policy without Congress. That reason sets up a line of reasoning, so the point is earned.
2/3evidence — Congress's power to declare war comes from the Constitution, a listed document. It is specific, accurate, and set against undeclared wars to support the claim. That earns 2 points. The third point needs a second specific piece, and none qualifies. The phrase a lot of wars names no war, president, or date, so it is too general to count. The Federalist paragraph does not count either. The single, energetic president argument is Federalist No. 70, and Federalist No. 51 was written by Madison, not Hamilton. That paragraph also argues against the writer's own thesis. The going-public paragraph describes the wrong thing too: meeting members one at a time is bargaining, and going public means using mass media to build public pressure. So the response stops at 2.
0/1reasoning — Each paragraph ends with a line like this shows presidents have too much power, which repeats the claim. The war paragraph comes closest, because it sets Congress's war power next to presidents fighting undeclared wars. Some readers might see that as implied reasoning. But it never states the because link. It would need a sentence such as: bypassing a declaration removes a check the Framers gave Congress, so the president now holds a power the design kept from him. Without that link, the point is not earned.
0/1rebuttal — The opposing view (presidents need emergency power) is named fairly. The reply just restates the thesis, with no refutation, concession, or evidence.
Keep the Electoral College or switch to a national popular vote · high-scoring response6/6

The United States should replace the Electoral College with a national popular vote. The current system lets a candidate win the presidency with fewer votes. It also pushes campaigns to ignore most of the country. A national popular vote would fix both problems, and it fits Madison's own argument for a large republic.

The clearest problem is that the Electoral College can override the majority. In 2000, Al Gore won about 540,000 more votes than George W. Bush nationwide. Bush still won 271 electoral votes to Gore's 266 after the Florida recount was stopped. In 2016, Hillary Clinton won about 2.9 million more votes than Donald Trump, but Trump won the Electoral College. Popular sovereignty means government gets its authority from the consent of the governed. When the person with fewer votes takes office twice in 16 years, the system breaks that principle.

Madison's reasoning in Federalist No. 10 also supports a national vote. Madison worried about factions, groups whose interests go against the rights of others or the good of the whole. His answer was a large republic. In a big, varied country, no single faction can easily become a majority. A winner must build a broad coalition. A national popular vote makes the whole country one constituency, which is the largest republic possible. Under winner-take-all, used in 48 states and DC, a candidate only needs narrow wins in a few swing states like Pennsylvania and Arizona. So the Electoral College lets a small set of voters decide, which is the opposite of the broad majority Federalist No. 10 counts on.

Supporters of the Electoral College argue that it protects small states and keeps power spread out, the way Brutus No. 1 wanted power kept close to the states. But the Electoral College does not protect small states in practice. Wyoming and Vermont get almost no campaign visits because they are safe for one party. What really matters is being a close state, not a small one. A national popular vote would make a voter in Wyoming worth exactly as much as a voter in Pennsylvania.

Because the Electoral College can defeat the majority and shrinks the electorate that matters, a national popular vote would better serve both popular sovereignty and Madison's large-republic design.

How it scored

1/1claim — The opening paragraph takes a clear position (replace it) and names the two lines of reasoning: overriding the majority and narrowing the campaign.
3/3evidence — The 2000 and 2016 results are specific and accurate, with correct vote totals. Federalist No. 10 is described correctly (factions, the large-republic remedy) and used to support the claim, not just mentioned. That is two specific pieces, and one comes from the list.
1/1reasoning — The response explains why a split result breaks popular sovereignty. It also explains why winner-take-all swing states shrink the coalition that Madison's large republic needs, which turns Federalist No. 10 into support for the claim.
1/1rebuttal — The response states the strongest counterargument (small states and Brutus-style fear of centralization). It refutes that argument with specific reasoning: small, safe states are ignored, and swing status, not size, decides attention.
Keep the Electoral College or switch to a national popular vote · mid-scoring response4/6

The Electoral College should be kept because it protects the states and makes candidates campaign across the whole country instead of only in big cities.

In Brutus No. 1, the author warned that the new federal government would grow too powerful and take over the states. The Electoral College helps stop this. Electors are chosen state by state, so a candidate has to win states, not just a national crowd. That keeps the states at the center of picking the president, which is the kind of check on national power Brutus wanted.

Federalist No. 10 also supports the Electoral College. In it Madison said that ambition has to be used to fight ambition, which means power has to be divided. The Electoral College divides power between the states.

The Electoral College also helps because most states use winner-take-all. To win the 270 electoral votes needed, a candidate has to win many different states with different kinds of voters, like farmers in Iowa and factory workers in Ohio. That means a president has to build a coalition that covers many regions. A candidate who only appealed to one area, like big coastal cities, could not win.

Some people say the Electoral College is undemocratic because sometimes the person with fewer votes wins. But if most Americans really wanted to get rid of it, Congress would have passed a law to abolish it by now. Since they have not, people must support the system.

The Electoral College should stay because it protects the states and makes candidates appeal to the whole country.

How it scored

1/1claim — The first sentence takes a defensible position (keep it) and gives reasons (protects states, forces a wide campaign) that set up a line of reasoning.
2/3evidence — Brutus No. 1 is described accurately and tied to the claim: the response says state-by-state selection is the check on national power Brutus wanted. That earns 2 points. The Federalist No. 10 paragraph earns nothing. The idea of setting ambition against ambition is from Federalist No. 51, and Federalist No. 10 is about controlling factions in a large republic. The Iowa and Ohio examples are too general to count as a second specific piece, so the third point is lost. The 270-vote target and winner-take-all are accurate, but they only describe how the system works. The paragraph never shows a real case, such as a named election where a candidate had to win many regions. So it claims the mechanism forces a broad coalition without proving it. A generous reader might credit these facts, but most would want that concrete example.
1/1reasoning — The Brutus paragraph explains how the credited evidence supports the claim. Because electors are chosen state by state, a candidate must win states, and that keeps states central in the way Brutus wanted. The link is short, but it explains why, not just what.
0/1rebuttal — The response names the opposing view (the popular-vote loser can win) but answers it with a false premise. Congress cannot abolish the Electoral College by passing a law. It is in Article II and the Twelfth Amendment, so removing it takes an Article V amendment. An amendment is proposed by two-thirds of both houses of Congress, or by a convention that Congress calls when two-thirds of the state legislatures apply for one. It is then ratified by three-fourths of the states, through their legislatures or ratifying conventions. The rebuttal rests on that error, so it does not earn credit.

Where points die

Mixing up the Federalist Papers. Students credit Federalist No. 51 with the single-energetic-president argument, or Federalist No. 10 with the idea of setting ambition against ambition. Learn one line per paper. No. 10 (Madison): factions are unavoidable, so a large republic keeps any one faction from taking over. No. 51 (Madison): separation of powers and checks so each branch can resist the others. No. 70 (Hamilton): one energetic executive who can act fast and be held accountable. No. 78 (Hamilton): the courts are the weakest branch. A paper you describe wrongly earns zero evidence credit, even when your argument is good.

Saying Federalist No. 78 calls the judiciary the weakest branch because judges have life tenure or the power of judicial review. Hamilton's reason is that the courts control neither the purse (Congress) nor the sword (the president). They have only judgment and need the executive to enforce their rulings. Life tenure is his argument for judicial independence. Judicial review is why the courts matter, not why they are weak.

Claiming Congress can get rid of the Electoral College, or change what the Constitution means, by passing an ordinary law. The Electoral College is written into Article II and the Twelfth Amendment. Changing the Constitution requires an Article V amendment. It is proposed by two-thirds of both houses of Congress, or by a convention that Congress calls when two-thirds of the state legislatures apply for one. It is ratified by three-fourths of the states, through their legislatures or ratifying conventions. A statute cannot do it. A rebuttal built on this error loses the point.

Describing going public as the president lobbying members of Congress one on one, or acting through governors or emergency powers. Going public means the president uses mass media, such as speeches, interviews, and social media, to rally voters. The voters then pressure Congress. Private meetings with members are bargaining, which is a different tool. If your evidence uses the term wrongly, it will not count.

Writing a rebuttal that names the other side and then repeats your thesis. The point needs a real answer. Refute it with a fact, concede part of it and explain why your claim still holds, or rebut it with a counterargument or counter-evidence that outweighs it. Use a pattern like this: opponents argue X; that is true for Y, but Z, because of a fact you name. Add a piece of evidence there if you can.

Ending every evidence paragraph with a line like this shows I am right and never explaining why. Reasoning is its own point. After each piece of evidence, write one sentence built on the word because that links the fact to your claim. For example: because the War Powers Resolution requires troops to come home within 60 days unless Congress approves, Congress kept the check Madison built into Federalist No. 51.

Score your own response

0 / 6

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.