Skip to content

Free-response practice

The SCOTUS Comparison question

4 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The SCOTUS Comparison is the third of four free-response questions on the AP U.S. Government and Politics exam. The free-response section lasts 100 minutes and is worth 50% of your score. Each of the four questions counts for 12.5% of the exam, so this 4-point question carries as much weight as the 6-point argument essay. Plan on about 20 minutes for it.

On this page · 6 sections

The prompt gives you a short summary of a Supreme Court case you were not required to study. That summary has the facts, the question the Court answered, and the holding. Your job is to connect it to one of the required cases you were supposed to learn, such as Tinker v. Des Moines, Shaw v. Reno or Citizens United v. FEC. The prompt names the required case, but it does not describe what that case was about; recalling those facts is entirely your responsibility.

There are three parts. Part A (1 point) asks you to identify the constitutional clause or principle the two cases share. Part B (2 points) asks you to explain how the facts of the two cases led to a similar or a different holding. Part C (1 point) asks about the real-world effect of the holding in the case you just read. It usually asks what a group, a state or Congress could do in response.

Readers score each point independently, and a point is either earned or not; there are no half points. A wrong statement does not cost you a point you already earned elsewhere, but it can stop you from earning the point it sits in. Readers want precision: name the clause, state the facts of the required case, and spell out the reasoning that links the facts to the outcome.

Know all 15 required cases cold: Marbury v. Madison, McCulloch v. Maryland, United States v. Lopez, Engel v. Vitale, Wisconsin v. Yoder, Tinker v. Des Moines, New York Times Co. v. United States, Schenck v. United States, Gideon v. Wainwright, Roe v. Wade, McDonald v. Chicago, Brown v. Board of Education, Baker v. Carr, Shaw v. Reno and Citizens United v. FEC. Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) overturned Roe. It is useful context, but it is not a required case. For each required case, memorize four things: the facts, the constitutional clause, the holding and the Court's reasoning.

The rubric, in plain terms

4 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Part A: Shared constitutional provision1 pt

Correctly names the specific clause, amendment or principle that both cases turn on. Examples: the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, or the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment. 'The Constitution' or 'civil rights' is too vague. Naming the wrong provision, such as the Fifteenth Amendment for a racial gerrymandering case, earns nothing.

Part B: Facts or holding of the required case1 pt

Accurately describes relevant facts and/or the holding of the required case. A separate incorrect statement elsewhere does not cancel accurate facts, but a description that gets the core facts or holding wrong earns nothing. Example: North Carolina drew an oddly shaped majority-Black district, and the Court said a district that can only be explained by race must pass strict scrutiny.

Part B: Explains the similarity or difference1 pt

Explains WHY the facts of the two cases led to the same or a different outcome. The response must point to a specific fact in each case and connect it to the Court's reasoning. 'Both cases were about free speech, so they are similar' only restates the topic and does not earn the point.

Part C: Real-world response or effect1 pt

Gives an action or effect that fits the holding of the non-required case and is legally possible, and explains how it connects to that holding. Answers that ignore the Court's power to have the last word on constitutional meaning, such as Congress 'passing a law to overturn' a constitutional ruling, earn nothing.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Racial gerrymandering: Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections and Shaw v. Reno

The following is a hypothetical case written for practice.

After the 2020 census, the legislature of the state of Westland drew a new map of its congressional districts. One new district, District 9, linked Latino neighborhoods in two cities about 90 miles apart. In the stretch between the cities, the district was in places no wider than a single highway. Emails between the mapmakers showed that they moved voters in and out of District 9 mainly by ethnicity. They did not rely on county lines, compactness or keeping towns whole. A group of voters living in District 9 sued. They argued that the state had sorted them by ethnicity without good reason.

In Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections (2024), the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 for the voters. The majority held that race or ethnicity was the main factor in drawing District 9. It said such a district must pass strict scrutiny. Westland had not shown that the district was narrowly tailored to serve a compelling government interest, so the district was struck down.

  1. (A)Identify the constitutional clause that is common to both Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections (2024) and Shaw v. Reno (1993). [1 pt]
  2. (B)Explain how the facts of Shaw v. Reno and the facts of Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections led to similar holdings. [2 pts]
  3. (C)Describe an action the Westland state legislature could take in response to the holding in Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections, and explain how that action relates to the holding. [1 pt]
Prompt 2

Campaign money: Westland Teachers Alliance v. Hollis and Citizens United v. FEC

The following is a hypothetical case written for practice.

The state of Westland passed a law limiting how much money any person, corporation, union or group may give directly to a candidate for governor. The limit is $2,000 per election. The law does not limit how much a group may spend on its own ads, as long as it does not coordinate with a campaign. The Westland Teachers Alliance, a union, wanted to give $50,000 straight to a candidate's campaign. It sued the state elections director, arguing that the limit violated its right to free speech.

In Westland Teachers Alliance v. Hollis (2023), the Supreme Court ruled 7-2 for the state and upheld the limit. The majority said large direct gifts to a candidate create a real risk of corruption, or the appearance of it, because the candidate may feel they owe the donor. The Court said preventing that kind of corruption is a strong enough interest to justify a cap on direct contributions. It noted that the union was still free to spend unlimited money on its own independent ads.

  1. (A)Identify the constitutional provision that is common to both Westland Teachers Alliance v. Hollis (2023) and Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission (2010). [1 pt]
  2. (B)Explain how the facts of Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission and the facts of Westland Teachers Alliance v. Hollis led to different holdings. [2 pts]
  3. (C)Describe an action an interest group in Westland could take to influence the governor's race in response to the holding in Westland Teachers Alliance v. Hollis, and explain how the action fits within that holding. [1 pt]

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Racial gerrymandering: Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections and Shaw v. Reno · high-scoring response4/4

A. Both cases involve the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.

B. In Shaw v. Reno, North Carolina drew a second majority-Black congressional district (District 12) that snaked along a highway. White voters sued. They said the shape was so bizarre that it could only be explained as an effort to sort voters by race. The Court agreed that this was a valid Equal Protection claim. It ruled that a district that can only be explained by race must pass strict scrutiny, and it sent the case back to the lower court to apply that test. In Delgado, Westland also drew a strange district, connecting Latino neighborhoods 90 miles apart with a strip only a highway wide. The mapmakers' emails showed ethnicity was the main reason voters were moved in or out. In both cases, the odd shape plus evidence of racial sorting meant the map could not be treated as ordinary line-drawing. That is why strict scrutiny applied both times, and both rulings went the voters' way. Delgado went one step further than Shaw. The Court applied strict scrutiny itself and found that Westland failed it.

C. The Westland legislature could redraw District 9 using traditional criteria like compactness, contiguity and keeping counties and towns together. This fits the holding because the Court only struck down the district since ethnicity was the predominant factor. A map where race is not the main factor would not trigger strict scrutiny.

How it scored

1/1A — Names the exact clause, the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. That is precise enough.
1/1B1 — Accurate Shaw facts: a second majority-Black district with a bizarre shape, challenged by white voters. Accurate holding: a district that can only be explained by race must pass strict scrutiny, and the Court sent the case back for the lower court to apply that test.
1/1B2 — Links specific facts in both cases (bizarre shape, evidence of racial sorting) to the same legal step, strict scrutiny. It explains why the results line up instead of just saying they do. It also gets the difference right: Shaw sent the case back, while Delgado applied the test and struck the district down.
1/1C — Gives a legal, realistic action (redraw using traditional criteria) and ties it to the holding: removing race as the main factor removes the reason the district failed.
Racial gerrymandering: Delgado v. Westland Board of Elections and Shaw v. Reno · mid-scoring response2/4

A. The Fifteenth Amendment, which protects the right to vote regardless of race, and the Voting Rights Act.

B. In Shaw v. Reno, North Carolina created a majority-minority district that had a really weird shape, and white voters said it was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court said that if the district could only be explained by race, it had to meet strict scrutiny. In Delgado, Westland's District 9 was also drawn around Latino voters with a strange shape. In both cases the weird shape and the use of race meant strict scrutiny applied, and the Court ruled against the state both times. The facts were basically the same.

C. The Westland legislature could pass a new law saying that drawing districts to help minority voters is allowed, which would overrule the Supreme Court's decision and let them keep District 9.

How it scored

0/1A — Wrong provision. Shaw was decided under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, not the Fifteenth. The Voting Rights Act is a federal statute, not a constitutional provision. Students often reach for the 'voting' amendment because the case is about districts.
1/1B1 — Correctly describes Shaw: a majority-minority district with an odd shape, challenged by white voters, and a holding that a district explainable only by race must meet strict scrutiny. One slip: Shaw did not finally rule against the state. The Court let the voters' claim go forward and sent the case back. The district was struck down later, in Shaw v. Hunt (1996). The point is still earned for the accurate facts and the strict-scrutiny holding.
1/1B2 — Earned, but only barely. The response names the same two facts in both cases, an irregular shape and the use of race, and says those facts are why strict scrutiny applied both times. That link between specific facts and the governing test is the minimum this point requires. The point comes from that link alone. The claim that the Court 'ruled against the state both times' is wrong for Shaw and earns nothing. A stronger answer would add that Delgado applied the test and struck the district down, while Shaw sent the case back.
0/1C — Not legally possible, because a state law cannot overrule a Supreme Court interpretation of the Constitution; changing that interpretation would require a constitutional amendment or a later Court decision. The action does not fit the holding.
Campaign money: Westland Teachers Alliance v. Hollis and Citizens United v. FEC · high-scoring response4/4

A. Both cases are about the free speech clause of the First Amendment.

B. In Citizens United, a nonprofit corporation wanted to air and advertise a film attacking Hillary Clinton shortly before the 2008 primaries. Federal law (the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act) banned corporations and unions from paying for this kind of election ad close to an election. The Court ruled 5-4 that the ban violated the First Amendment. Its reasoning was that independent spending is political speech and is not coordinated with a candidate, so it does not create quid pro quo corruption. In Westland Teachers Alliance, the union wanted to give money directly to a candidate's campaign. That difference in facts is why the holding is different. A direct contribution goes into the candidate's own hands, so it creates a risk that the candidate will trade favors for the money. The Court said preventing that corruption justifies a limit. So Citizens United protected independent expenditures, while Westland upheld a cap on direct contributions.

C. The Teachers Alliance could form an independent-expenditure committee (the state version of a super PAC) or use its own funds to run independent ads supporting its candidate, as long as it does not coordinate with the campaign. This fits the holding because the Court only upheld the cap on direct gifts and said independent spending was still unlimited, which is consistent with Citizens United.

How it scored

1/1A — Correctly identifies the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment.
1/1B1 — Accurate Citizens United facts (a corporation's film near the primaries, the BCRA ban on corporate-funded election ads) and holding (the ban violates the First Amendment).
1/1B2 — Pins the different outcome to the key factual difference, independent spending versus a direct contribution, and explains the Court's reasoning about corruption risk for each.
1/1C — A realistic, legal action (an independent-expenditure committee or the union's own independent ads) that fits inside the holding. The response says why: the cap covers only direct gifts.
Campaign money: Westland Teachers Alliance v. Hollis and Citizens United v. FEC · mid-scoring response2/4

A. The First Amendment freedom of speech.

B. In Citizens United v. FEC the Supreme Court ruled that money is speech and that corporations can give as much money as they want to candidates. In Westland the Court said there could be a limit on donations. So the cases are different because in Citizens United there was no limit and in Westland there was a $2,000 limit. The Court probably changed its mind because people were worried about too much money in politics.

C. An interest group could run its own TV ads for the candidate it likes without working with the campaign. The Court said groups could still spend unlimited money on their own ads, so this would still be allowed under the ruling.

How it scored

1/1A — Correct. The Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment is common to both.
0/1B1 — This misstates Citizens United, a very common error. The decision invalidated limits on independent expenditures; it did NOT allow corporations to contribute unlimited money directly to candidates. Direct corporate contributions to federal candidates are still banned. The response also gives no facts of the case.
0/1B2 — It says the outcomes differ but only restates them ('no limit' versus 'a limit'). It does not point to the real factual difference (independent spending versus direct contributions). Guessing that the Court 'changed its mind' replaces reasoning with speculation.
1/1C — A legal action that fits the holding, and the link to the Court's statement about independent spending is explained.

Where points die

Naming the general topic instead of the clause in Part A, for example 'voting rights' or 'freedom of expression.' Another version is naming the wrong amendment, such as the Fifteenth Amendment for a gerrymandering case. Name the exact clause and amendment the Court used. Racial gerrymandering (Shaw) and school segregation (Brown) are Equal Protection Clause cases under the Fourteenth Amendment. Tinker, Schenck, New York Times and Citizens United are Free Speech or Free Press Clause cases under the First Amendment. Engel is the Establishment Clause. Yoder is the Free Exercise Clause.

Saying Congress or a state legislature could 'pass a law to overturn' the Court's ruling in Part C. A statute cannot change what the Constitution means; altering a constitutional interpretation requires an Article V amendment or a later Court decision. The most common amendment route is a two-thirds vote in both houses of Congress to propose, then ratification by three-fourths of the states. Article V also lets Congress call a national convention to propose amendments when two-thirds of the state legislatures (34) apply for one. Either way, an amendment takes effect only after three-fourths of the states (38) ratify it, through their legislatures or through state conventions. Realistic responses work inside the holding: redraw a map using non-racial criteria, rewrite a law more narrowly, move money to independent spending, file a new lawsuit, or lobby for an amendment.

Describing a required case from memory without its actual facts, or getting its holding backwards. The classic version claims Citizens United lets corporations give unlimited money directly to candidates. Part B's first point depends on accurate facts. Citizens United struck down limits on independent corporate and union spending on election advertising, while direct corporate contributions to federal candidates remain prohibited. For every required case, memorize who sued, what the government did, which clause applied and what the Court decided.

Writing 'both cases are about free speech, so they are similar' as the Part B explanation. Sharing a clause is what Part A rewards; Part B requires a specific fact from each case and the reasoning that connects it to the result. Example: Tinker's armbands caused no substantial disruption, so the school could not punish the students. If the new case involves speech that did disrupt school, the holding can differ even though the clause is the same.

Explaining a different holding as the Court 'changing its mind' or switching to a 'living Constitution' approach. Readers reward reasoning built on facts, not guesses about justices' moods or theories of interpretation. Living constitutionalism and originalism describe how judges interpret the Constitution; they do not explain why two cases with different facts produced different outcomes. Point to the factual difference the Court relied on.

Treating judicial power as unlimited in Part C, for example saying the Court will enforce its ruling itself. In Federalist No. 78, Hamilton called the courts the 'least dangerous' branch because they control neither the budget nor the military. They depend on the other branches and on state governments to implement their rulings. Good Part C answers often name the officials who must act: a legislature redrawing a map, Congress rewriting a statute, or a group changing its tactics.

Score your own response

0 / 4

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.