The table shows hypothetical data on Senate votes on five treaties, each of which the president had negotiated and signed. All 100 senators voted on each treaty.
| Treaty | Senators voting yes | Senators voting no |
|---|---|---|
| Treaty P | 71 | 29 |
| Treaty Q | 64 | 36 |
| Treaty S | 67 | 33 |
| Treaty T | 49 | 51 |
| Treaty U | 80 | 20 |
Based on the data in the table, which of the following statements about the Senate's role in treaty ratification is accurate?
- ATreaty S failed because it fell short of the two-thirds vote required
- BTreaty Q failed even though most senators voted for itCorrect
- CTreaty T would have been ratified if two more senators had voted yes
- DTreaty P passed by the narrowest margin of any ratified treaty
Why B is right
Article II, Section 2 requires two-thirds of senators present to consent to a treaty; with all 100 voting, that is 67 votes. The table shows Treaty Q received 64 yes votes and 36 no votes: a clear majority, but three short of two-thirds, so a 36-senator minority blocked a treaty the president had already signed. This illustrates the interbranch tension the supermajority rule creates. Treaties P (71), S (67), and U (80) met the threshold; Treaty T (49) did not even win a majority.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the threshold: Treaty S received 67 of 100 votes, which meets the two-thirds requirement (66.7 rounded up), so it was ratified.
- C
- Confuses a simple majority with the supermajority: two more yes votes would make Treaty T 51-49, still far short of the 67 needed.
- D
- Wrong row: among ratified treaties, Treaty S (67-33) had the narrowest margin, not Treaty P (71-29).