The table shows hypothetical data on how the nine justices of the Supreme Court voted at conference on five petitions for a writ of certiorari.
| Petition | Justices voting to grant review | Justices voting to deny review |
|---|---|---|
| Petition 1 | 3 | 6 |
| Petition 2 | 4 | 5 |
| Petition 3 | 5 | 4 |
| Petition 4 | 2 | 7 |
| Petition 5 | 9 | 0 |
Based on the data in the table and the Supreme Court's procedure for selecting cases to hear on appeal, which petitions would the Court accept for review?
- AOnly Petitions 3 and 5, because a majority of the justices must agree before the Court will grant review
- BOnly Petition 5, because the Court grants review only when all nine justices agree to hear a case
- CAll five petitions, because the Court must hear every appeal that raises a federal question
- DPetitions 2, 3, and 5Correct
Why D is right
Under the 'rule of four,' certiorari is granted when at least four of the nine justices vote to hear a case. In the table, Petition 2 (4 votes), Petition 3 (5 votes), and Petition 5 (9 votes) each reach the four-vote threshold, so all three are accepted. Petitions 1 (3 votes) and 4 (2 votes) fall short and are denied, leaving the lower-court ruling in place. A grant does not require a majority, so Petition 2 is accepted even though five justices voted to deny.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Applies a majority (five-vote) threshold instead of the rule of four, wrongly excluding Petition 2, which has the four votes needed.
- B
- Treats unanimity as the standard; a grant needs only four votes, so Petitions 2 and 3 would also be accepted.
- C
- Assumes mandatory jurisdiction; the Court's appellate docket is almost entirely discretionary, so Petitions 1 and 4, which lack four votes, are denied.