The following is a practice passage.
For decades the justices have decided, one claim at a time, whether a particular guarantee in the first eight amendments is fundamental enough to limit the states. Free speech passed this test long before the right to counsel did, and some protections still have not passed it at all. Such a method leaves the scope of a citizen's liberty to the shifting judgment of whichever justices happen to sit on the Court. The amendment adopted after the Civil War was meant to end that uncertainty. Its promise that no state may deprive any person of liberty without due process of law should carry every one of those guarantees with it, completely and at once.
Which of the following best describes the argument made in the passage?
- AThe Court should stop applying Bill of Rights guarantees to the states and leave the protection of liberties to state constitutions.
- BThe Court's right-by-right method of applying guarantees to the states is too unpredictable, and all of the first eight amendments should bind the states fully.Correct
- CThe Court has acted properly by applying guarantees to the states one at a time, deciding in each case whether a right is fundamental.
- DCongress, rather than the federal courts, should decide which Bill of Rights guarantees apply to state and local governments.
Why B is right
The passage describes selective incorporation, in which the Court uses the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause to decide right by right which Bill of Rights guarantees bind the states. Free speech was incorporated in Gitlow v. New York (1925), the right to counsel much later in Gideon v. Wainwright (1963), and some guarantees, such as grand jury indictment, are still not incorporated. The author objects that this method depends on 'the shifting judgment' of the justices. The author argues that the due process promise should carry 'every one of those guarantees,' 'completely and at once,' which is the total incorporation position. Choice B states that argument. Choice C describes the Court's actual approach, which is the one the passage criticizes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The author wants more protection against the states, not less. The passage says the Due Process Clause should carry every guarantee against the states, which rejects the Barron v. Baltimore view that the Bill of Rights limits only the national government.
- C
- This describes selective incorporation, the approach the Court actually followed. The passage criticizes that approach as leaving liberty to the shifting judgment of the justices, so the author would not call it proper.
- D
- The passage says nothing about shifting the decision to Congress. Its complaint is about the Court's method, and its remedy is applying every guarantee to the states through the amendment itself, not leaving the choice to legislators.