Read the following practice passage.
A state jury convicted a seventeen-year-old of murder after a trial in which he was represented by appointed counsel and his confession was found to be voluntary. On appeal, his lawyers did not dispute the conviction. Instead, they argued that the death sentence imposed on him was excessive. They pointed out that most states no longer execute offenders who were under eighteen when they committed their crimes, and they cited research showing that adolescents are more impulsive and more susceptible to peer pressure than adults. A sentence that society now regards as disproportionate, they contended, cannot stand, even if it was permitted when the state's law was written.
The argument made by the lawyers in the passage most directly relies on which of the following constitutional provisions?
- AThe Fifth Amendment's protection against compelled self-incrimination during questioning
- BThe Sixth Amendment's guarantee of the assistance of counsel for the defense
- CThe Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection clause applied to age-based state laws
- DThe Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishments as applied to sentencesCorrect
Why D is right
The lawyers in the passage concede the trial was fair (counsel provided, confession voluntary) and attack only the sentence, arguing that it is excessive, that a national consensus among states has moved against executing juvenile offenders, and that what society now regards as disproportionate cannot stand. That is the reasoning of the Eighth Amendment's ban on cruel and unusual punishments, interpreted according to evolving standards of decency, which the Supreme Court used in Roper v. Simmons (2005) to bar the death penalty for offenders under eighteen.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage states the confession was found to be voluntary and the lawyers do not dispute the conviction, so self-incrimination is not the basis of their argument.
- B
- The passage notes the defendant had appointed counsel, and the appeal does not challenge the trial; the right to counsel is not what the lawyers invoke.
- C
- Although the defendant's age matters, the lawyers do not argue that juveniles are treated unequally compared with a similarly situated group; they argue the punishment itself is excessive and disproportionate.