Read the following practice passage.
Critics often blame the winner-take-all rules used in American congressional elections for the weakness of minor parties. That explanation is overstated. Americans do not reject minor parties because the rules punish them; they reject them because the Democratic and Republican coalitions are broad enough to absorb nearly every major demand voters make. When a new issue gains a following, one of the two major parties adopts it, and the minor party that raised it fades. Changing the way votes are counted would leave this pattern largely intact, because voters would still prefer the major parties on the merits.
Which of the following findings would most directly challenge the author's argument?
- AMost voters who identify with a major party report that its positions closely match their own policy views.
- BMany voters who prefer a minor-party candidate vote for a major-party candidate because they expect the minor party to lose.Correct
- CIn places that adopted ranked-choice ballots, minor-party candidates won about the same share of first-choice votes as before.
- DMinor parties have drawn the most votes in years when both major parties ignored an issue that many voters cared about.
Why B is right
The author argues that minor parties are weak because voters genuinely prefer the broad major-party coalitions, and that the winner-take-all rules are not the cause. A finding that voters who actually prefer a minor-party candidate still vote for a major party because they expect the minor party to lose shows that the rules themselves drive the result. Under single-member plurality rules, a vote for a likely loser is a wasted vote, so voters vote strategically. This is the mechanism behind Duverger's Law, which holds that single-member plurality systems tend toward two dominant parties, and it directly contradicts the passage. Choices A, C, and D are all consistent with the author's preference-based explanation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- This supports the author. The passage says voters choose the major parties because those parties' broad coalitions already reflect what voters want.
- C
- This supports the author. The passage predicts that changing how votes are counted would leave minor-party support largely unchanged, and this finding shows exactly that.
- D
- This fits the author's claim that minor parties gain a following only when an issue is left unaddressed, and fade once a major party adopts it.