Employment Division v. Smith (1990) held that a neutral, generally applicable law can be enforced against religious practice without a religious exemption. Oregon denied unemployment benefits to two men fired for using peyote in a Native American Church ceremony, and the Court upheld the denial.
Why it matters
Smith narrowed the Free Exercise Clause, because the government no longer needs a compelling interest to burden religion through a general law. Congress pushed back with the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (1993), which restored strict scrutiny by statute. The Court answered in City of Boerne v. Flores (1997), ruling that RFRA could not be applied to the states, so it binds only the federal government.
How the exam tests it
Questions give several laws and ask which can be enforced against a religious group. Under Smith, a law is treated as neutral and generally applicable only if it does not single out religion and does not exempt comparable secular conduct. Such a law needs only a rational basis. A law that targets religious rituals must pass strict scrutiny, which it almost always fails, as in Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye v. Hialeah (1993). Public support or the law's age does not matter.
Don’t confuse it with
Students mix up Smith with Sherbert v. Verner (1963), but Sherbert required strict scrutiny for burdens on religion, while Smith limits that strict test mostly to laws that target religion or allow case-by-case exemptions. Smith did not overrule Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972), which let Amish parents take their children out of school after eighth grade. It distinguished Yoder as a case that joined free exercise with parents' rights.