When the president issues an executive order that is challenged in federal court, courts typically ask which key threshold question to determine whether the order is valid?
- AWhether the order rests on constitutional or statutory authority without conflicting with a statuteCorrect
- BWhether the president personally drafted the order or delegated its drafting to agency officials
- CWhether the order received bipartisan support from at least some members of the opposition party in Congress
- DWhether the order aligns with the party platform and the campaign promises the president was elected on
Why A is right
Courts evaluating executive orders ask: Is the action within the president's constitutional authority as commander-in-chief or chief executive? If Congress has spoken on the matter, does the order comply with or contradict that statute? Justice Jackson's framework in Youngstown Sheet & Tube v. Sawyer (1952) provides the standard: presidential power is strongest when acting with congressional authorization and weakest when defying it.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Who physically drafts an executive order is irrelevant legally; what matters is whether the authority behind it falls within presidential power.
- C
- Bipartisan support may be politically relevant but is not a legal requirement; executive orders can be legally valid without any opposition support.
- D
- Consistency with the party platform or the president's campaign promises is a political consideration, not a legal standard for validity; courts evaluate executive orders against constitutional and statutory law.