The Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment protects religious practice from government interference. Following Employment Division v. Smith (1990), which standard applies when a neutral, generally applicable law incidentally burdens religious practice?
- AThe government must demonstrate a compelling interest and use the least restrictive means to justify any burden on religion
- BAny law that substantially burdens a sincere religious practice is automatically unconstitutional under the Free Exercise Clause
- CNeutral laws of general applicability that incidentally burden religion need only satisfy rational basis reviewCorrect
- DThe burden on religious practice must be so substantial as to amount to a direct prohibition before the courts will intervene
Why C is right
In Employment Division v. Smith, the Supreme Court held that neutral laws of general applicability that incidentally burden religious practice do not violate the Free Exercise Clause and need only satisfy rational basis review. The heightened scrutiny standard (from Sherbert v. Verner) was limited to individualized exemption systems.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- This was the pre-Smith standard from Sherbert v. Verner; Smith lowered the bar for neutral, generally applicable laws.
- B
- Automatic unconstitutionality was rejected in Smith; courts distinguish between targeted laws directed at religion (unconstitutional) and neutral laws with incidental religious burdens (generally constitutional).
- D
- Courts do not require a near-total prohibition on practice; even substantial incidental burdens from neutral laws are constitutionally permissible under Smith.