The Great Compromise at the Constitutional Convention resolved the conflict between large and small states over congressional representation by
- ACreating a unicameral legislature in which each state received representation proportional to its population
- BCreating a bicameral legislature in which the House is apportioned by population and each state has two senatorsCorrect
- CGiving large states additional electoral votes in presidential elections to compensate for equal Senate representation
- DCreating a rotating presidency among the states, with each state's governor serving a one-year presidential term
Why B is right
The Great Compromise (Connecticut Compromise), proposed by Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth, resolved the conflict between the Virginia Plan (proportional representation in both chambers) and the New Jersey Plan (equal state representation). The compromise created a bicameral Congress: the House of Representatives with seats apportioned by population (favoring large states) and the Senate with two seats per state regardless of population (protecting small states). This structure remains unchanged today.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the Great Compromise specifically created a bicameral legislature to give small states equal representation in one chamber; a unicameral proportional body was the large-state position that small states rejected.
- C
- Incorrect because the Electoral College formula (states receive electoral votes equal to House seats plus two Senate seats) does give small states a slight advantage, but this was not the primary mechanism of the Great Compromise; that was bicameralism in Congress.
- D
- Incorrect because there was never a proposal for a rotating presidency among state governors; the Constitutional Convention created a single executive selected through the Electoral College.
Read the following practice passage, which describes a delegate's argument at the Constitutional Convention.
A delegate from a populous state argues that the people, not the state governments, are the true source of the new national government's authority. If a state with ten times as many inhabitants as its smallest neighbor receives the same voice, then the votes of some citizens count for far less than the votes of others. At least one chamber of the national legislature should therefore be chosen directly by the people, and each state's share of seats in that chamber should rise or fall with the number of its inhabitants. Only then, the delegate concludes, will national laws reflect the will of the governed.
The delegate's argument most directly supports which feature of the Constitution?
- AA Senate in which each state has two members chosen by its state legislature
- BA single-chamber Congress in which every state casts one equal vote
- CA system in which state legislatures choose the members of both chambers of Congress
- DA House of Representatives elected directly by the people, with seats apportioned among the states by populationCorrect
Why D is right
The passage makes two claims. First, authority comes from the people, so at least one chamber should be chosen directly by them. Second, a state's share of seats should rise or fall with its number of inhabitants. Both claims match the House of Representatives in Article I, Section 2: members are elected by the people every two years, and seats are apportioned among the states by population. This was the Virginia Plan principle that survived the Great Compromise. The passage does not support the Senate's equal representation, the Articles' one-state-one-vote Congress, or state legislatures choosing members of both chambers, because each of these gives states equal weight or cuts the people's direct role.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Equal state representation in the Senate, with senators originally chosen by state legislatures, was the small-state position (New Jersey Plan, adopted in the Great Compromise). It is exactly what the delegate objects to: giving a large state and a small state the same voice.
- B
- A unicameral legislature with one vote per state describes the Articles of Confederation and the New Jersey Plan. The passage argues against equal state votes because they make some citizens' votes count for less.
- C
- Having state legislatures choose members of both chambers contradicts the passage's claim that the people, not state governments, are the source of authority, and its call for one chamber chosen directly by the people.
The 'discharge petition' is a congressional procedure in the House of Representatives that allows:
- AThe Speaker to remove legislation from a committee that has failed to report a bill after a set deadline
- BThe minority party to demand a floor vote on any legislation that has been stalled in committee for more than 30 days
- CA majority of House members (218) to force a bill out of committee and onto the floor without committee approvalCorrect
- DThe President to request that the House take up a bill as an emergency measure, bypassing normal committee procedures
Why C is right
A discharge petition allows 218 House members (a simple majority) to sign a petition forcing a bill out of committee and onto the House floor for a vote, bypassing the committee that has blocked it. This procedure is rarely successful because members who sign may face retaliation from committee chairs and party leadership, but it represents a tool for rank-and-file members to circumvent leadership control.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the Speaker's removal of legislation from committee without a discharge petition is not a standard procedure; this describes a related but distinct concept.
- B
- Incorrect because the minority party does not have this right unilaterally; a discharge petition requires 218 signatures, which typically means significant majority party support since the minority usually numbers fewer than 218.
- D
- Incorrect because the President has no formal power to force the House to take up specific legislation; the bully pulpit can pressure Congress, but not procedurally compel floor action.