Read the following practice passage.
Critics call it obstruction, but the custom serves a purpose worth keeping. When a federal judgeship opens in a state, the chair of the committee that reviews judicial nominees asks both of that state's senators whether they object to the nominee, and for decades chairs of both parties declined to schedule a hearing for anyone a home-state senator would not approve. Nothing in the Constitution or the Senate's written rules requires this. Yet the custom forces presidents to consult senators who know the local bar, and it gives the minority party a voice it would otherwise lack once a simple majority can confirm. A chair who abandons the custom gains speed but gives up that check.
Which of the following statements is most consistent with the author's argument in the passage?
- AThe custom helps preserve the minority party's influence over lower-court appointments now that a simple majority can confirm nominees.Correct
- BBecause the custom has no basis in the Constitution or in Senate rules, the committee chair should stop honoring it.
- CThe custom is justified mainly because it shields the selection of federal judges from the policy preferences of the sitting president.
- DHome-state senators' objections should bind the committee only for appellate nominees, whose rulings reach beyond a single state.
Why A is right
The passage describes the Judiciary Committee's informal blue-slip custom, in which the chair has historically declined to hold hearings for nominees a home-state senator objects to. That gives home-state senators an effective veto that rests on committee norm, not constitutional text. The author offers two reasons for keeping it: it forces presidents to consult home-state senators, and it 'gives the minority party a voice it would otherwise lack once a simple majority can confirm.' Choice A restates the second reason, so it is most consistent with the argument. B is the critics' position, which the author rejects. C gives a rationale the author never offers. D sets up an appellate-only limit the passage does not discuss.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The author concedes that nothing in the Constitution or written Senate rules requires the custom but argues it should be kept anyway; B states the critics' conclusion the author rejects.
- C
- The author defends the custom because it forces presidents to consult home-state senators, not because it removes presidential influence; the president still nominates, and the passage never claims the custom insulates selection from presidential preferences.
- D
- The passage describes the custom applying to a judgeship opening in a state and never distinguishes appellate from trial-court nominees or argues for limiting the custom to one kind of court.