The 'delegation of authority' problem in administrative law arises because Congress often passes broadly worded statutes leaving key policy decisions to agencies. The major questions doctrine, invoked in West Virginia v. EPA (2022), requires which of the following?
- ACongress must explicitly name each industry an agency may regulate whenever a rule touches on greenhouse gas emissions or climate policy
- BAgency rules that cost more than $100 million annually must receive specific legislative authorization from Congress
- CAgencies must apply strict scrutiny to major regulations to ensure they serve compelling governmental interests
- DFor decisions of vast economic and political significance, agencies need clear congressional authorization for that specific actionCorrect
Why D is right
The major questions doctrine holds that when an agency claims authority to take regulatory actions of vast economic and political significance, courts will require clear congressional authorization for that specific action — not just a plausible textual reading. In West Virginia v. EPA, the Court applied this to limit EPA's authority to restructure the electricity grid under Clean Air Act provisions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The doctrine imposes no industry-by-industry or emissions-specific authorization requirement; it governs assertions of broad new authority in any policy domain, not just greenhouse gases or climate.
- B
- The $100 million figure is the threshold for a 'significant regulatory action' triggering OIRA/OMB review under Executive Order 12866, not the trigger for the major questions doctrine.
- C
- Strict scrutiny is a tier of constitutional rights review; the major questions doctrine is a statutory-interpretation canon requiring clear congressional authorization, not a compelling-interest test.