Skip to content
AP U.S. Government and Politics · Interactions Among Branches of Government

McGrain v Daugherty

McGrain v Daugherty appears in 3 reviewed AP U.S. Government and Politics questions and sits in Interactions Among Branches of Government. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

McGrain v. Daugherty (1927) held that Congress has an implied power to investigate and to compel witnesses to testify, because lawmakers cannot write sound laws without facts. The case grew out of the Senate's Teapot Dome inquiry into Attorney General Harry Daugherty's Justice Department.

Why it matters

It is the constitutional basis for congressional oversight, from committee hearings to subpoenas. The limit matters too: the inquiry must relate to a subject Congress could legislate on, not just expose someone's private affairs.

How the exam tests it

Expect a passage arguing that the power to investigate follows from the power to legislate, then a question about what the author would accept. The trap is thinking partisan motives spoil an inquiry. They do not, as long as a valid legislative purpose exists.

Don’t confuse it with

Executive privilege, which is the president's claim to withhold information from Congress; McGrain is about Congress's power to demand it.

McGrain v Daugherty in real questions

Example 1Harder
The following is a practice passage. Nothing in Article I mentions investigations, yet the power to inquire follows from the power to make laws. A legislature cannot write sound statutes about conditions it does not understand, and people who hold the needed facts rarely volunteer them fully or accurately, so the power must include the ability to compel testimony. That same reasoning also fixes its boundary: an inquiry is legitimate only when it could inform a law Congress has authority to pass. Exposing a person's private affairs for its own sake, or merely to shape public opinion, serves no legislative end. Still, judges should not probe the hearts of committee members; if a valid legislative subject exists, mixed political motives do not spoil it. The author of the passage would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
  1. AHearings are justified chiefly by Congress's duty to keep the public informed about government.
  2. BPartisan motives alone do not invalidate an inquiry.Correct
  3. CCourts should weigh committee members' political motives before enforcing a congressional subpoena.
  4. DCongress should rely on voluntary testimony, since compelled testimony is often incomplete or unreliable.

Why B is right

The passage ends by saying that judges should not examine committee members' motives, and that when a valid legislative subject exists, mixed political motives do not spoil it. So the author would agree that partisan motives alone do not invalidate an inquiry. The passage's view tracks the reasoning of McGrain v. Daugherty (1927). Congress's power to investigate is implied from its power to legislate, and it includes compulsory process. It is limited to inquiries that could inform legislation, so exposure for its own sake is not legitimate.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The passage rejects an informing rationale: an inquiry meant merely to shape public opinion 'serves no legislative end.' The only justification it accepts is informing a law Congress could pass.
C
This reverses the passage's last point. The author says judges should not probe the hearts of committee members, and that mixed political motives do not spoil an inquiry on a valid legislative subject.
D
This misreads the passage. The author notes that volunteered information is often incomplete or inaccurate, and draws the opposite conclusion: the power must include the ability to compel testimony.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Interactions Among Branches of Government.