Skip to content
AP U.S. Government and Politics · Civil Liberties and Civil Rights

Near v Minnesota

Near v Minnesota appears in 5 reviewed AP U.S. Government and Politics questions and sits in Civil Liberties and Civil Rights. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Near v. Minnesota (1931) struck down a state law that let judges shut down 'malicious' or 'scandalous' newspapers as public nuisances. The Court held that prior restraint, stopping publication before it happens, is almost always unconstitutional.

Why it matters

Near incorporated freedom of the press against the states through the Fourteenth Amendment and created the presumption against prior restraint that decided the Pentagon Papers case forty years later. The press may be punished after publishing libel, but it cannot be gagged in advance except in extreme cases, like printing troop movements in wartime.

How the exam tests it

Questions ask you to identify a prior restraint in a scenario: a court order or license requirement that blocks publication ahead of time. A fine or lawsuit after publication is not a prior restraint.

Don’t confuse it with

Prior restraint stops speech before it happens; subsequent punishment, such as a libel judgment, comes after publication, and only the first triggers Near's near-absolute ban.

Near v Minnesota in real questions

Example 1Medium
Which of the following scenarios most clearly illustrates the constitutional principle of 'prior restraint' and how the Supreme Court typically treats it?
  1. AA school district removes books from library shelves after parents complain about their content
  2. BThe government obtains a court order barring a newspaper from publishing classified documentsCorrect
  3. CA court orders a publisher to pay damages for defamatory statements after they are published
  4. DCongress passes a law making it a crime to knowingly publish certain categories of harmful speech

Why B is right

Prior restraint refers to government action that prevents speech or publication from occurring in the first place, before it reaches the public. Obtaining a court injunction to stop a newspaper from publishing is the classic prior restraint form. The Supreme Court established a strong presumption against prior restraints in Near v. Minnesota (1931) and upheld that presumption in New York Times Co. v. United States (1971) — the Pentagon Papers case — where the Court refused to enjoin publication.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Library book removal raises First Amendment concerns but does not constitute prior restraint in the traditional sense, which requires government action to prevent specific speech from reaching the public.
C
Paying damages after publication is a subsequent punishment, not a prior restraint; this form of speech regulation is more constitutionally permissible than pre-publication restraints.
D
Criminal laws punishing published speech are subsequent punishments, not prior restraints; while such laws raise First Amendment concerns, they do not involve the pre-publication prevention that defines prior restraint.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Civil Liberties and Civil Rights.