Under the Administrative Procedure Act, federal agencies publish proposed rules and accept public comments before issuing final rules. The table shows hypothetical data on five proposed federal rules.
| Proposed rule | Comment period (days) | Comments received | Share of comments from interest-group form letters | Final rule revised after comments? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Power plant emissions limits | 60 | 410,000 | 92% | Yes |
| Overtime pay eligibility | 60 | 280,000 | 85% | Yes |
| Drone registration | 30 | 9,500 | 12% | Yes |
| Food labeling standards | 90 | 46,000 | 64% | No |
| Bank capital requirements | 75 | 18,000 | 21% | No |
Which of the following statements is supported by the data in the table?
- AThe rule that drew the most comments also had the largest share of comments from interest-group form letters.Correct
- BEvery proposed rule with a comment period of 60 days or longer received more than 100,000 comments.
- CThe rule with the smallest share of form-letter comments was the only rule the agency revised after the comment period.
- DRules with a larger share of form-letter comments were less likely to be revised by the agency before being finalized.
Why A is right
In the table, the power plant emissions rule received the most comments (410,000) and also had the highest share from interest-group form letters (92%), so A is supported. This reflects how the APA's notice-and-comment process lets citizens and interest groups submit written comments on proposed rules, and how organized groups often mobilize members to send large numbers of comments. B fails for the 90-day and 75-day rules, C ignores the two other revised rules, and D reverses the relationship shown in the data.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Misreads the comment-period column: the food labeling rule (90 days) received only 46,000 comments and the bank capital rule (75 days) only 18,000.
- C
- Drone registration did have the smallest form-letter share (12%) and was revised, but the emissions and overtime rules were also revised, so it was not the only one.
- D
- Reverses the pattern: the two rules with the highest form-letter shares (92% and 85%) were both revised, while the two unrevised rules had lower shares (64% and 21%).