Read the following practice passage.
A statewide association of independent pharmacists spent two years lobbying for a law that raised the reimbursement rates paid to every pharmacy in the state. The law passed, and all pharmacies began receiving the higher rates. In the following year, however, the association's membership fell by nearly a third. Several pharmacy owners who let their memberships lapse explained that they saw little reason to keep paying annual dues, since the higher rates applied to their stores whether or not they belonged. The association responded by offering discounted liability insurance and continuing-education credits available only to dues-paying members.
Which of the following challenges facing interest groups is best illustrated by the passage?
- APharmacy owners could keep the benefits of the group's policy win without paying to support itCorrect
- BRival groups with opposing goals lobbied the legislature to offset the association's influence on policy
- CMembers with conflicting policy preferences disagreed over which lobbying strategy to pursue
- DCampaign finance rules restricted how closely the group could coordinate its spending with candidates for office
Why A is right
The passage shows the collective action (free-rider) problem: the higher reimbursement rates were a collective benefit received by every pharmacy, so owners told the association they could keep the benefit without paying dues, and membership fell by nearly a third. The association's response, offering liability insurance and continuing-education credits only to dues-paying members, is the selective-incentive strategy Mancur Olson described for overcoming this problem.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Competition from opposing groups is a real feature of pluralist politics, but the passage describes no rival group; the law passed, and the association's problem came afterward from its own potential members.
- C
- Internal disagreement over strategy is a genuine challenge for interest groups, but the owners in the passage left because the benefit reached them anyway, not because they disputed the association's lobbying approach.
- D
- Campaign finance limits on coordination are real constraints, but the passage involves lobbying for a reimbursement law and says nothing about electoral spending or candidates.