New York Times Co. v. United States (1971), the Pentagon Papers case, refused to let the Nixon administration block newspapers from publishing a leaked classified history of the Vietnam War. The Court held the government had not met the heavy burden needed to justify a prior restraint.
Why it matters
It is a required case because it shows a national security claim losing to the First Amendment. Daniel Ellsberg leaked the study, and the Times and the Washington Post began printing it. The Court heard argument on June 26 and ruled 6 to 3 on June 30, 1971, less than three weeks after the first story ran, that the government had not met the heavy burden needed to justify a prior restraint.
How the exam tests it
Questions pair this case with Near v. Minnesota and ask you to recognize a prior restraint: the government seeking a court order to stop publication of classified material. Know that the ruling did not make leakers immune from prosecution; it only barred stopping the presses.
Don’t confuse it with
In Schenck v. United States (1919), speech was punished after the fact under the clear and present danger test; both cases involve national security, but the Court protected the press in 1971 and upheld the conviction in 1919.