Under Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, jurisdictions covered by the act's formula had to submit proposed changes to their voting laws or procedures for federal approval before putting them into effect. The table shows hypothetical data on proposed voting changes in four states over a ten-year period.
| State | Required to obtain federal approval? | Proposed voting changes | Changes submitted for federal review | Changes blocked by federal reviewers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State P | Yes | 400 | 400 | 20 |
| State Q | Yes | 250 | 250 | 25 |
| State R | Yes | 120 | 120 | 18 |
| State S | No | 310 | Not required | Not applicable |
Which of the following statements is supported by the data in the table?
- AState P had the most changes blocked, which shows that submitting more proposals led to more federal objections.
- BState R had the highest share of its submitted changes blocked, though it submitted fewer than States P and Q.Correct
- CState S had its proposed voting changes blocked at a lower rate than any state required to seek approval.
- DState Q submitted more proposed changes and had more of them blocked than State P did.
Why B is right
Divide each state's blocked changes by its submitted changes: State P 20/400 = 5%, State Q 25/250 = 10%, State R 18/120 = 15%. State R had the highest share blocked even though it submitted the fewest changes of the three states required to seek approval (120, compared with 250 and 400). State S was outside the federal approval requirement, so its changes took effect without federal review. That is the point of preclearance: only covered jurisdictions needed advance federal approval for voting changes. In Shelby County v. Holder (2013), the Court struck down the coverage formula that decided which jurisdictions had to seek this approval.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Misreads the blocked column: State Q (25), not State P (20), had the most changes blocked, so the causal claim built on it also fails.
- C
- State S was not required to obtain federal approval, so none of its 310 changes were reviewed or blocked; the table gives no blocking rate for S to compare.
- D
- Reverses the comparison: State Q submitted 250 changes against State P's 400, even though Q had more blocked (25 vs. 20).
Read the following practice passage.
Fifty years ago, Congress had good reason to single out certain states and counties for special treatment. Today, a county on that list must still wait for officials in Washington to approve something as minor as moving a polling place across the street, while a neighboring county with lower turnout and a worse record makes the same change without asking anyone. The list itself rests on registration and turnout figures from the 1960s and early 1970s. A burden placed on some states but not others should be justified by present conditions, not by statistics older than most of today's voters.
The author of the passage would most likely support which of the following changes to the federal law described?
- APlacing elections in low-turnout counties under the direct administration of federal officials
- BBasing the formula that decides which places need federal approval of voting changes on recent dataCorrect
- CRequiring every state and county to get federal approval before making any change to its voting rules
- DKeeping the existing list of covered places unchanged so that earlier patterns of discrimination cannot return
Why B is right
The passage describes the Voting Rights Act of 1965's preclearance requirement (Section 5), under which covered jurisdictions had to obtain federal approval before changing voting procedures, and the coverage formula (Section 4) that decided which jurisdictions were covered using 1960s-70s registration and turnout data. The author does not reject federal protection of voting rights outright but argues that the burden placed on some states and not others must be justified by present conditions rather than old statistics. That points to updating the coverage formula with recent data (B), the same reasoning the Court used in Shelby County v. Holder (2013).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The author objects to the extent of federal involvement in some places' elections; nothing in the passage favors expanding federal control to direct administration of elections.
- C
- Although the author complains that only some places carry the burden, the passage says any burden must be justified by present conditions; imposing it on every state regardless of conditions contradicts that standard.
- D
- This is the position the author argues against: the passage criticizes the list for resting on decades-old registration and turnout figures.
Under Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act (before Shelby County v. Holder, 2013), states with a history of racial discrimination in voting were required to
- Asubmit annual reports to the Federal Election Commission documenting the racial composition of their registered voter rolls
- Bobtain advance approval ('preclearance') from the Justice Department or a federal court before changing any voting laws or proceduresCorrect
- Cconduct all federal, state, and local elections under direct federal supervision, with federal marshals stationed at every polling place
- Dmaintain proportional racial representation in their state's congressional delegation through mandatory race-conscious redistricting
Why B is right
Section 5 of the Voting Rights Act required covered jurisdictions (determined by Section 4's coverage formula: states/counties with low minority turnout and use of discriminatory tests as of 1964/1968/1972) to obtain federal preclearance before implementing any change to voting laws, procedures, or district maps. The Justice Department or D.C. District Court had to certify that the change would not have a discriminatory purpose or effect. In Shelby County v. Holder (2013), the Supreme Court struck down the Section 4 coverage formula, effectively suspending preclearance because no jurisdiction could be covered under an invalid formula.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Section 5 preclearance was administered by the Justice Department (Civil Rights Division) and the D.C. District Court, not the Federal Election Commission; the FEC oversees campaign finance and has no role in Voting Rights Act enforcement or in documenting the racial composition of voter rolls.
- C
- Incorrect because Section 5 did not place elections under permanent federal supervision with marshals at every polling place; it required administrative preclearance review of proposed voting changes, a bureaucratic paperwork process rather than an armed federal presence on election day.
- D
- Incorrect because the VRA prohibits the purposeful dilution of minority voting strength but does not mandate proportional racial representation in a state's delegation; if anything, decisions like Shaw v. Reno restrict race-conscious redistricting rather than require it.