The legal source a president must point to for any action: a power in Article II, or a power Congress delegated by statute. An executive order that rests on neither is invalid. An order that contradicts a statute sits at the lowest ebb of presidential power and almost always falls.
Why it matters
Presidents issue hundreds of executive orders, and this test decides which ones stand. Justice Jackson's concurrence in Youngstown Sheet & Tube v. Sawyer (1952) set the framework. Presidential power is strongest when Congress has approved the action, uncertain when Congress is silent, and weakest when the president defies Congress.
How the exam tests it
The stem describes an executive order challenged in court and asks what threshold question judges apply. The answer is whether the order rests on constitutional or statutory authority without conflicting with an act of Congress. Popularity and efficiency are not the test.
Don’t confuse it with
Students assume the title of chief executive is blanket authority. Youngstown held that Truman could not seize steel mills on that basis when Congress had chosen a different method.