A religious exemption is a release from a law so that a person can follow a religious practice the law would otherwise forbid or burden. Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972), the required case, granted one. Amish parents could take their children out of school after eighth grade despite Wisconsin's compulsory attendance law. The Court weighed the state's interest in schooling against the burden on Amish faith and found no compelling reason to override the parents.
Why it matters
Employment Division v. Smith (1990) later narrowed that approach. It held that the Free Exercise Clause does not require an exemption from a law that is neutral toward religion and applies to everyone. Smith did not overrule Yoder; it recast Yoder as a hybrid case that joined free exercise with parental rights. If a law singles out religious conduct, as Hialeah's animal sacrifice ordinances did in Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye v. Hialeah (1993), it faces strict scrutiny and almost always falls.
How the exam tests it
Yoder is the case the exam expects when a stimulus describes a religious group asking to be released from a general law. The credited answer is that the Free Exercise Clause required an exemption because the state's interest did not outweigh the burden on sincere religious practice. Smith-style tables describe several ordinances and ask which one the city can enforce against a religious group without an exemption. Pick the law that covers everyone and lists no secular exemptions, because carve-outs for non-religious conduct destroy general applicability. Ignore distractor columns like year enacted or public support.
Don’t confuse it with
Students read Smith to mean that a law burdening worship never requires an exemption. But in Yoder the Amish won one from a neutral attendance law, and Yoder is still the required case. After Smith, a neutral law that applies to everyone usually needs no exemption unless it targets religion or exempts comparable secular activity.