Read the following practice passage.
In a mid-sized city, a council committee held public hearings on where to build a new bus depot. Nearly all of the residents who testified, wrote letters to the committee, or donated to council members' campaigns that year lived in the Hillcrest district, where most adults hold college degrees and household incomes are well above the city average. Residents of the Eastside district, where many adults work hourly jobs with irregular shifts, rarely appeared at the evening hearings. The committee placed the depot in Eastside, citing the large volume of input it had received from Hillcrest residents opposing a site in their neighborhood.
Which of the following conclusions is best supported by the passage?
- ARestrictive voter registration rules in Eastside lowered turnout in council elections, which is why Eastside lost influence over the siting decision
- BParty organizations ran get-out-the-vote drives in Hillcrest but not Eastside, so partisan mobilization explains which residents testified
- CThe committee set aside public input and chose the Eastside site mainly because cost estimates showed it was the cheapest location available
- DResidents with more education, income, and control over their time supplied most of the input the committee received, and that uneven input shaped where the depot was placedCorrect
Why D is right
The passage says the people who testified, wrote letters, and donated came almost entirely from Hillcrest, the district with more college graduates and higher incomes. Eastside residents, whose hourly jobs and irregular shifts kept them from evening hearings, rarely took part. The committee then based its decision on the input it received. This is the socioeconomic participation gap: people with more time, money, and civic skills take part at higher rates, so officials hear their preferences more often and those preferences shape policy. Choice D is the only one that matches the details of the passage. A and B bring in causes the passage never mentions, and C contradicts the committee's stated reason.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Registration rules can depress turnout, but the passage never mentions elections, registration, or turnout. The participation it describes is testifying, writing letters, and donating, so this explanation has no support in the source.
- B
- Party mobilization does raise participation, but the passage says nothing about parties or get-out-the-vote efforts. It links the difference to education, income, and work schedules (hourly jobs with irregular shifts versus evening hearings).
- C
- This contradicts the passage. The committee explicitly cited the volume of input from Hillcrest residents as its reason, and the passage never mentions cost estimates.