The following is a practice passage.
Some judges hunt through the first eight amendments for hints of a right to privacy, piecing together the ban on quartering soldiers in homes, the limits on searches, and the protection against self-incrimination. That hunt is unnecessary, and it invites the charge that judges are inventing rights out of shadows. A simpler foundation exists. After the Civil War, the nation promised that no state could take away a person's liberty without fair process. Liberty has never meant only freedom from physical restraint; it includes the freedom to make the most intimate decisions about marriage and family life without state interference.
Which of the following best describes the constitutional basis for the right to privacy that the author of the passage endorses?
- APrivacy is implied by several specific Bill of Rights guarantees that, taken together, create a protected zone of personal life
- BPrivacy is part of the liberty that the Fourteenth Amendment bars states from taking without due process of lawCorrect
- CPrivacy is among the unlisted rights retained by the people under the Ninth Amendment, which judges must enforce directly
- DPrivacy is protected chiefly by the Fourth Amendment limits on government searches of homes and papers
Why B is right
The author rejects the method of combining several Bill of Rights guarantees (quartering, searches, self-incrimination) to find privacy and offers 'a simpler foundation': the post-Civil War promise that no state may take away a person's liberty without fair process. That promise is the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The passage then reads 'liberty' broadly enough to cover intimate decisions about marriage and family. This is the substantive due process approach of Justice Harlan's Griswold v. Connecticut (1965) concurrence, which later became the main basis for privacy rulings. Penumbras (A), the Ninth Amendment (C) and the Fourth Amendment (D) have all been offered as sources of privacy, but the passage supports only the due process basis.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- This is the penumbra reasoning from Justice Douglas's Griswold opinion. The passage describes it ('piecing together' the Third, Fourth and Fifth Amendment protections) and then rejects it as unnecessary and open to the charge of 'inventing rights out of shadows.'
- C
- Justice Goldberg's Griswold concurrence relied on the Ninth Amendment, but the passage never mentions rights retained by the people. It rests its argument on the post-Civil War promise about liberty.
- D
- The passage lists the limits on searches only as one of the pieces that other judges stitch together, then dismisses that whole approach. It does not treat the Fourth Amendment as the main source of privacy.
The concept of 'substantive due process' differs from 'procedural due process' in that substantive due process:
- AGives individuals the right to challenge the substantive content of criminal charges before trial through preliminary hearings
- BRequires that the procedures used to deprive someone of life, liberty, or property be fair and appropriate, including notice and hearing
- CRequires courts to review the substance of legislative debates before determining whether a law was validly enacted
- DHolds that certain fundamental rights cannot be infringed upon by government regardless of how fair the procedures areCorrect
Why D is right
Procedural due process requires fair procedures when the government deprives someone of life, liberty, or property (notice, hearing, impartial decision-maker). Substantive due process holds that certain fundamental rights are so important that no amount of fair procedure can justify infringing them — the substance of what government does, not just how it does it, is limited. Griswold v. Connecticut (contraception), Roe v. Wade, and Obergefell all relied on substantive due process.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because preliminary hearings in criminal cases are a procedural due process right; substantive due process is a broader constitutional doctrine about fundamental liberty interests.
- B
- Incorrect because this describes procedural due process, which focuses on the fairness of the PROCESS used to deprive rights; substantive due process is about what the government can deprive, not how.
- C
- Incorrect because legislative debate review is not what substantive due process entails; the doctrine identifies fundamental rights that government cannot limit, regardless of the legislative process used.