The table shows hypothetical data on federal immigration removals (deportations) in the year before and the year after a president issued a directive setting enforcement priorities under the Article II duty to "take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed." The underlying immigration statutes did not change between the two years.
| Category of individual | Removals, year before directive | Removals, year after directive |
|---|---|---|
| Convicted of serious crimes | 82,000 | 91,000 |
| Recent border crossers | 110,000 | 118,000 |
| Arrived as children, no criminal record | 14,000 | 1,200 |
| Long-term residents, no criminal record | 36,000 | 36,500 |
Which of the following conclusions about the president's use of executive power is best supported by the data?
- AThe president halted enforcement of immigration law as a whole, since total removals fell sharply
- BRemovals declined in every category, reflecting a general cut in federal enforcement resources
- CEnforcement was sharply deprioritized for one category while removals in others held steady or roseCorrect
- DThe president pardoned people who arrived as children, erasing their pending removal cases altogether and permanently
Why C is right
The table shows removals of people who arrived as children with no criminal record falling from 14,000 to 1,200, a drop of more than 90 percent. Over the same period, removals rose in every other category: convicted criminals (82,000 to 91,000), recent border crossers (110,000 to 118,000), and long-term residents with no criminal record (36,000 to 36,500). Total removals stayed nearly flat (242,000 to 246,700). Because the statutes did not change, this pattern points to prosecutorial discretion: the president chose which violations to prioritize instead of stopping enforcement altogether. Presidents justify enforcement priorities like this under the Take Care Clause, and DACA is the real-world example. Critics argue that categorical non-enforcement goes beyond discretion and amounts to failing to faithfully execute the law.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Total removals actually rose slightly (242,000 to 246,700), and three categories increased, so the data do not show a general halt to enforcement. This confuses selective non-enforcement with abandoning the law.
- B
- Misreads the table: removals rose in three of the four categories, so the decline was not across the board and does not point to an overall resource cut.
- D
- The pardon power applies to federal crimes, not to civil removal proceedings, and the data still show 1,200 removals in that category. The pattern reflects enforcement priorities (prosecutorial discretion), not pardons.