The table shows hypothetical data on how four members of the House of Representatives voted on the same bill, along with the share of each member's district that supported the bill and each member's personal view of it.
| Representative | District support for the bill | Member's personal view | Member's vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| W | 72% | Opposed | Yes |
| X | 68% | Opposed | No |
| Y | 35% | Supported | Yes |
| Z | 55% | Supported | Yes |
Based on the data in the table, which representative's behavior most clearly illustrates the delegate model of representation, as distinct from the trustee model?
- ARepresentative Z, because the vote matched both the district majority and the member's own view of the bill
- BRepresentative X, because the member relied on personal judgment even though most constituents favored the bill
- CRepresentative W, because the member voted with the district majority despite personally opposing the measureCorrect
- DRepresentative Y, because the member supported the bill although only a minority of the district backed it
Why C is right
Under the delegate model, a legislator acts as an agent of constituents and votes as they wish even when personally opposed. In the table, Representative W personally opposed the bill but voted Yes because 72% of the district supported it, which is the clearest case of setting aside one's own judgment to follow constituents. Representatives X and Y voted their own views against the district majority (the trustee model), and Representative Z's district and personal view agreed, so Z's vote cannot distinguish one model from the other.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Z's district majority (55%) and personal view both favored the bill, so the Yes vote is consistent with either model and does not show the delegate model as distinct from the trustee model.
- B
- Incorrect because X voted No on personal judgment while 68% of the district supported the bill; following one's own conscience over constituents is the trustee model.
- D
- Incorrect because Y voted Yes on personal judgment while only 35% of the district supported the bill; overriding constituent opinion this way also reflects the trustee model.