The following is a practice passage.
During a hypothetical state senate race, news outlets published polls every week showing Candidate Reyes with a growing lead. Marta, who had supported Reyes's opponent since the spring, told her neighbors she was now voting for Reyes because nearly everyone she knew seemed to be heading that way. Daniel, who had no preferred candidate, received so many survey calls that he resolved to make sure he voted, still undecided. Priya urged the trailing candidate she worked for to adopt Reyes's popular property-tax plan. Owen, a pollster hired by the Reyes campaign, designed survey questions whose wording made Reyes look stronger than other surveys did.
Which person in the passage most clearly illustrates the bandwagon effect associated with horse-race polling?
- AOwen, the pollster hired by a campaign
- BDaniel, the undecided resident
- CPriya, the staffer for the trailing campaign
- DMarta, the longtime opposition supporterCorrect
Why D is right
The bandwagon effect is the tendency of some citizens to change their stated opinions or vote choices toward the candidate who appears to be winning. In the passage, Marta drops the candidate she had backed since spring and moves to Reyes, who leads in the weekly published polls, because nearly everyone seems to be heading that way. That is the bandwagon effect. Each of the other people reacts to polling in a different way: Owen biases poll wording, Daniel is mobilized to vote without choosing a candidate, and Priya pushes her candidate toward the opponent's policy position.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Owen writes question wording that favors his client. That is biased or slanted poll design, a problem with how the poll is built. It does not show a voter changing preference because of who appears to be winning.
- B
- Daniel is pushed by repeated survey contact to commit to voting, but he does not pick a candidate. That is a mobilization (question-behavior) effect, not a shift toward the perceived winner.
- C
- Priya's candidate would be borrowing a popular policy from the opponent. That is strategic policy convergence by a campaign. It is not citizens changing their own vote choice to match the apparent frontrunner.
The concept of 'retrospective voting' in political science refers to voters who:
- AChoose candidates based on their position on a single issue that the voter cares about deeply, ignoring all other aspects of the candidate's record or platform
- BVote for the same candidate in every election based on longstanding party identification formed during childhood and adolescence through political socialization
- CEvaluate candidates by the incumbent's past performance, rewarding officeholders when recent conditions have been good and punishing them when conditions have been badCorrect
- DResearch candidates' full voting records and policy histories before casting a ballot, using comprehensive historical information to make thoroughly informed electoral choices
Why C is right
Retrospective voting theory (V.O. Key, Morris Fiorina) holds that many voters make their decisions based on how things have gone during the incumbent's time in office—especially economic conditions. 'Pocketbook voting' (based on personal financial situation) or 'sociotropic voting' (based on national economic conditions) are forms of retrospective voting. This creates accountability: incumbents who preside over prosperity win reelection; those who preside over recessions lose. Economic voting research shows GDP growth rate is a strong predictor of incumbent vote share.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because voting based on a single issue is 'single-issue voting' or 'issue-public' voting, a different phenomenon; retrospective voting is about evaluating overall incumbent performance based on outcomes, not about prioritizing one issue over all others.
- B
- Incorrect because voting based on longstanding party identification (party-line voting) is explained by party identification theory (Campbell et al., 'The American Voter'), not retrospective voting; retrospective voters focus on recent performance, which may cause them to deviate from their party identification.
- D
- Incorrect because thoroughly researching candidates' full histories describes an idealized 'rational voter' or 'informed voter' model, not retrospective voting; retrospective voting uses simpler evaluative shortcuts based on observable outcomes (Is the economy good?), not comprehensive policy research.