Read the following practice passage.
A state enacted a law requiring every voter to show a government-issued photo ID at the polls. The state issues the ID free of charge, but only at driver-license offices, and last year it closed the offices in six rural counties with large Black populations. A critic of the law does not question the state's authority to guard against fraud, and she does not claim that legislators meant to discriminate. Her argument is narrower: because of where the closures fell, the law's practical result is that Black citizens in those counties have less opportunity than other citizens to cast a ballot, and a federal statute forbids voting rules that produce that result, whatever their purpose.
Which of the following pieces of evidence, if true, would most directly strengthen the critic's argument as described in the passage?
- ATurnout in the state fell by about the same percentage among every racial group after the law took effect
- BBlack residents of the six counties are less likely than white residents to hold a qualifying IDCorrect
- CThe state charges a fee for the birth certificate that many residents need to obtain the free photo ID
- DInvestigations in the state found almost no cases of in-person voter impersonation in recent elections
Why B is right
The passage's critic makes a narrow claim. She concedes that the state may guard against fraud and that legislators did not intend to discriminate, and argues only that the law's practical RESULT leaves Black citizens with less opportunity to vote. That is the results-based test of Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, which does not require proof of discriminatory intent. Evidence that Black residents of the affected counties are less likely to hold a qualifying ID (B) shows the racially unequal effect her argument depends on. A shows an equal effect across groups, which weakens her claim. C supports a general cost-burden argument rather than a racial-results one. D goes after the state's fraud rationale, which the passage says she does not dispute.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- A drop that is the same for every racial group shows a general burden, not a racially unequal result, so it would weaken the critic's claim that Black citizens in particular have less opportunity to vote. Students who think any turnout decline helps a challenge will pick this.
- C
- A hidden fee supports a general burden or poll-tax style argument, but the passage's critic argues about a racially unequal result, and a fee charged to all residents does not show that result.
- D
- Evidence that fraud is rare challenges the state's justification, but the passage says the critic does not question the state's authority to guard against fraud. Her argument does not depend on it.