- AThe President must comply with all congressional subpoenas for documents, including those related to national security
- BExecutive privilege is a valid constitutional doctrine but not absolute and yields to a specific criminal subpoenaCorrect
- CPresidential communications enjoy an absolute privilege that shields them from disclosure in any judicial proceeding
- DA sitting President cannot be criminally indicted while in office but may be prosecuted after leaving the presidency
Why B is right
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the ruling was about criminal judicial subpoenas, not congressional subpoenas; the Court distinguished between the two and recognized executive privilege exists even if not absolute.
- C
- Incorrect because the Court ruled the opposite — executive privilege is NOT absolute; this absolute privilege claim was what Nixon argued and the Court rejected.
- D
- Incorrect because US v. Nixon addressed executive privilege over documents/tapes, not presidential criminal immunity; the question of indicting a sitting president was not resolved there.