The 1896 Supreme Court decision, 7 to 1, upholding a Louisiana law requiring separate railway cars by race. Justice Henry Billings Brown's majority held that a legal distinction between races does not by itself destroy legal equality, establishing the "separate but equal" doctrine under the Fourteenth Amendment. Justice John Marshall Harlan dissented alone, arguing the Constitution recognizes no ranked classes of citizens.
Why it matters
This is the constitutional license for Jim Crow, and it held for fifty-eight years. Read it alongside the machinery it protected: the Mississippi Plan of 1890, poll taxes, literacy tests, and grandfather clauses that stripped Black Southerners of the vote while claiming to be race-neutral on their face.
How the exam tests it
Two reliable angles. A quoted passage from the majority opinion asks what it most directly reflects, and the credited answer is the legal framework enabling segregation across Southern public life for roughly six decades. Alternatively a Brown v. Board of Education (1954) stem asks which precedent was overturned, and Plessy is the answer.
Don’t confuse it with
Distinguish it from the Civil Rights Cases of 1883, which struck down the federal ban on discrimination by private businesses. That decision limited what Congress could reach; Plessy went further and blessed segregation the states themselves imposed.