Read the following summary of Eugene Debs's view of the Pullman Strike, drawn from his statements and later writings, and answer the question.
According to Eugene Debs, the Pullman strike of 1894 exposed the extent of one man's control over workers' lives: George Pullman owned the town, the factory, the workers' housing, the company stores, and even the church — and he had raised rents while cutting wages. When workers protested, Pullman refused to negotiate, and the federal government responded by sending troops to break the strike. Debs came to see this not as an ordinary labor dispute but as proof that concentrated property and corporate power could override democratic government.
Debs's analysis most directly reflected which of the following implications of the Pullman Strike?
- AThe Pullman company-town model as inherently unstable, showing that paternalistic corporate control of workers' housing, wages, and worship inevitably bred resistance
- BThe constitutionality of labor injunctions as a strike-breaking tool, a power the Supreme Court soon affirmed in In re Debs (1895) for use against later strikes
- CThe failure of the American Railway Union's sympathy boycott as a tactic, showing that solidarity strikes could not effectively pressure large interstate corporations
- DThe federal government as an instrument of capitalist class power, since the Cleveland administration's injunction and troops showed the state was not neutral in labor-capital conflictsCorrect
Why D is right
Debs's view that the strike revealed 'the power of property over democratic government' became central to his radicalization toward socialism. The federal injunction and troop deployment demonstrated, in his view, that the state served capital against labor — converting him from a trade unionist to a socialist political organizer.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- While the company-town model did breed instability, Debs's argument centers on the federal government's intervention to crush labor, not on the company town's economic logic.
- B
- While In re Debs (1895) upholding injunctions was legally significant, Debs's statement is about the political-class power demonstrated, not about the specific legal mechanism used.
- C
- While the boycott did fail tactically, Debs's statement focuses on the deeper political lesson — federal power serving capital — not on tactical analysis of the boycott's effectiveness.